2023-07-06 14:34:55
Compulsory Vaccination Not Effective Solution for Decreased Vaccination Rates, Experts Say
The vaccination rate of young children has once again fallen this year, according to a recent report by the National Institute for Public Health and the Environment. In an attempt to combat this decline, compulsory vaccination has often been suggested as a solution. However, experts argue that such measures are not the best approach.
The Metro panel, consisting of health economist Eline van den Broek-Altenburg, health law professor Martin Buijsen, and chairman of AJN Jeugdartsen Nederland Astrid Nielen, strongly believes that mandatory vaccination is not morally or ethically desirable. Van den Broek-Altenburg pointed out that individuals have the right to determine what happens to their bodies, including whether or not they receive medical procedures such as vaccinations.
The experts also emphasized the importance of providing accurate information about the risks and benefits of vaccines. Van den Broek-Altenburg cited the example of the HPV vaccine, which had serious side effects in the past but has since improved with new generations of the vaccine. She argued that individuals should be able to make informed choices about their vaccinations, and it is the government’s responsibility to provide information to citizens.
Buijsen agreed with the panel’s statement, highlighting that while there is currently no support in the Netherlands for compulsory vaccination, it is legally possible to introduce such measures. He mentioned other European countries that have implemented mandatory vaccination, with penalties for non-compliance. However, he acknowledged that any restrictions on individual rights must be regulated by law, proportionate, and necessary.
Nielen expressed concern that compulsory vaccination could have a counterproductive effect, particularly among parents who have doubts or questions about vaccines. She emphasized the importance of open communication and targeted information to increase vaccination coverage. Nielen cited the danger of diseases like measles, which require high vaccination rates to achieve herd immunity.
The experts also warned against the government’s focus on the health economic aspect of vaccination. Buijsen stressed the need to prioritize individual autonomy and not solely consider the cost-saving benefits of vaccines. He cited the example of the rotavirus vaccination, which was not included in the mandatory package despite the potential risks, as it would not save significant costs compared to the relatively small number of children affected.
In conclusion, the Metro panel emphasizes the importance of individual autonomy, informed decision-making, and open communication to address the declining vaccination rates among children. They warn against the implementation of compulsory vaccination, which they believe is not an effective or ethical solution.]
#Compulsory #vaccination #good #measure #declining #vaccination #coverage #children