Title: Ultra-Orthodox protesters demonstrate against conscription law in Modi’in Illit
Subtitle: An inside look at the recent protest and the challenges faced
Thursday evening saw the entrance junction to Modi’in Illit, the stronghold of Torah scholars and popularly known as the ‘City of the Elders’, become the site of a protest against the conscription law in Israel. The event caught many residents by surprise, as the majority were unaware of the drama unfolding just a few meters away from their homes.
With limited access to information, as many lack WhatsApp or are not part of online groups, it was challenging for the news to reach the city’s residents. Only a handful of people came out to witness the demonstration, which consisted of approximately 40 protesters. Despite the commotion, the demonstration remained peaceful, and there were no reports of violence.
The police authorities in Modi’in Illit deserve credit for their handling of the situation. They ensured that the protesters did not block the city’s sole entrance and exit, emphasizing the importance of maintaining smooth traffic flow for the 85,000 inhabitants. The police held their ground and treated both sides with respect and fairness throughout the demonstration.
Yair Drori, a senior official of the city police, received praise for his role in managing the event. Comparing their behavior to previous extremist demonstrations, it became evident that this protest lacked the presence of any Haredi extremists. The peaceful demonstration aimed to highlight the grievances surrounding the conscription law.
One of the protesters approached a journalist and explained the reasons behind their opposition to the law. They argued for equal treatment, emphasizing that there were ultra-Orthodox mothers and fathers in their community who were deeply committed to their faith. The protesters demanded equality and called for universal conscription, regardless of religious background.
The journalist extended empathy towards the protesters. The interviewee spoke of the difficulties faced by ultra-Orthodox families, expressing concern for their sons who may be conscripted into the military at the age of 18. The journalist acknowledged the devotion of these mothers and fathers, stating that they would willingly risk their lives for the sake of Torah study if necessary.
However, the journalist believed that if the protesters had a deeper understanding of the broader society, the values held dear, and the volunteers who respond to calls for help, they might view the issue differently. The journalist emphasized the importance of gaining a more comprehensive perspective.
During the demonstration, a mother whose son had been wounded in battle recounted her sorrow, expressing the pain she felt as others did not serve. This poignant moment resonated with the journalist, who embraced her and expressed understanding. The exchange of stories with other mothers and a respectful conversation with another protester further humanized the importance of this issue for the ultra-Orthodox community.
With the approaching winter session of the Knesset, tensions are likely to rise as the debate over the conscription law continues. The ultra-Orthodox community cannot disregard the impact this legislation will have on their very homes and families. The challenge to find a resolution that respects both religious freedom and the unity of the nation looms ahead.
The journalist concluded by expressing the need for understanding between differing communities. They hoped that through mutual understanding, both their own beliefs and the belief in a state that respects the faith of all its citizens can coexist. They called for political leaders, regardless of their background, to choose their words carefully and act responsibly, safeguarding the integrity of the nation.
In the coming year, the journalist prays for a society that fosters dialogue and empathy, as well as positive and helpful communication from elected officials. They hope that by treating each other with respect, all citizens of Israel can contribute to a strong and inclusive nation.