Title: Comedian Judd Apatow’s Directorial Debut Falls Flat in “Old Dads”
Publication Date: Friday, October 20, 2023
In his latest film, “Old Dads,” renowned comedian Judd Apatow takes a step behind the camera to explore the struggles of three older fathers as they navigate a changing world and rail against political correctness. Unfortunately, the film proves to be a bitter misfire that fails to capture the comedic magic of Apatow’s previous works.
Throughout the 21st century, Apatow has been known for his ability to portray the transition from young manhood to responsible adulthood. Movies like “Knocked Up” and “This is 40” highlighted the need for characters to let go of immaturity and embrace their responsibilities. However, in “Old Dads,” Apatow’s attempt to replicate this narrative with an ensemble in their 50s misses the mark.
The film revolves around the characters Jack (played by Bill Burr), Connor (played by Bobby Cannavale), and Mike (played by Bokeem Woodbine). These three friends long for the good old days when they could bend the rules without consequence. They are portrayed as victims of a society that they believe has become too politically correct and “pussified” their alpha male personas. Their disdain for political correctness becomes a central theme as they find themselves caught up in cancel culture after deadnaming Caitlyn Jenner.
Facing the consequences of their actions, the trio is left unemployed and burdened with their parental duties. The plot takes a familiar turn as they embark on a Vegas road trip to rediscover themselves, echoing the storyline from “Knocked Up.” While it is predictable that they will eventually find redemption, the film fails to present a fresh perspective or engage the audience emotionally.
Bill Burr, a seasoned stand-up comedian known for his incisive comic powers, co-authored the script with Ben Tishler. However, the dialogue comes across as a reactionary and stale, as Burr’s character spews out tired complaints instead of providing genuine observations. Burr attempts to position himself as a voice brave enough to address popular grievances found on social media but instead falls flat.
While Bobby Cannavale and Bokeem Woodbine give earnest performances as well-meaning characters, Burr’s portrayal of Jack is filled with bitterness and annoyance. Throughout the film, he radiates frustration with the modern world, but his growth is limited to learning when to keep his opinions to himself. This limited character development fails to create a strong enough foundation for the movie’s premise.
In summary, “Old Dads” is a disappointing directorial debut for Judd Apatow. The film lacks the comedic brilliance and fresh perspective seen in his earlier works. While the idea of exploring the challenges faced by older fathers in a changing society is intriguing, the execution falls short. Ultimately, the film fails to entertain or resonate with audiences, leaving viewers craving the wit and humor that Apatow is renowned for.