Ranked-Choice Voting Explained: New York City Voters Embrace New System in Upcoming Primary
New York City voters are heading to the polls with a new tool in hand: ranked-choice voting. As the primary elections approach on Tuesday, residents have the prospect to rank up to five candidates for offices including mayor, public advocate, comptroller, borough president, and city council, with early voting already underway through sunday.
the New York City board of Elections describes this system as a way to give voters “more choices and can lead to more diverse winners,” with 74% of New York voters already utilizing it in primary and special elections for city offices.
This shift represents a relatively recent change for New Yorkers, implemented following a voter referendum in 2019. Though, the concept isn’t entirely new, already being used in Maine and Alaska and gaining traction nationwide.
To understand the mechanics and rationale behind this evolving electoral process, Amy Goodman of Democracy Now! spoke with John Tarleton, editor-in-chief of The Indypendent. Tarleton explained that ranked-choice voting was first adopted in San Francisco in 2004 and is now utilized in approximately 40 cities and towns across the United States, including Oakland, Colorado’s Boulder, Minneapolis, Burlington, Vermont, and Takoma Park, Maryland.
Tarleton highlighted a core issue the system aims to address: the potential for “wasted” or “spoiled” votes in traditional winner-take-all elections. He illustrated this point with the 2000 presidential election in Florida, where Ralph Nader received 97,000 votes while Al Gore ultimately lost the election by a mere 537 votes. “If there had been ranked-choice voting,” Tarleton noted, “Green Party supporters…could have made Al Gore their second choice.”
This allows voters to support their preferred candidate without fear of inadvertently aiding the election of someone they strongly oppose. As Tarleton explained, the system empowers voters by allowing them to express both their top choice and a secondary preference, preventing a scenario where a vote for a less popular candidate inadvertently benefits the least desirable option.
The system was first instituted in New York City elections in 2021. Under the current rules, New York voters can rank candidates in order of preference, selecting up to five choices. This has fundamentally altered the dynamics of the election landscape.
You can view the full interview with John Tarleton online. Early voting continues through Sunday in readiness for Tuesday’s New York City primary for mayor.
.
This article is part of a broader effort by Democracy Now!, which is currently seeking a Senior Headline News Producer, a Director of Audience, and a director of Technology. More information on these opportunities can be found at democracynow.org/jobs. Democracy Now! is produced by a dedicated team including Mike Burke, Renée Feltz, Deena Guzder, Messiah Rhodes, Nermeen Shaikh, maria Taracena, Tami Woronoff, Charina Nadura, Sam Alcoff, tey-Marie Astudillo, John hamilton, Robbie Karran, Hany Massoud, Anjali Kamat, Safwat Nazzal, with Julie Crosby serving as executive director. Special thanks were also extended to Becca Staley, Jon Randolph, Paul Powell, Mike Di Filippo, Miguel Nogueira, Hugh Gran, Denis Moynihan, david Prude, and Dennis McCormick.
The Mechanics of Ranked-Choice Voting: A Deeper Dive
As new Yorkers navigate the ranked-choice voting system in the upcoming primary,understanding the process is key. Beyond simply ranking candidates, it’s crucial to grasp how thes preferences are translated into election results.
The core of ranked-choice voting (RCV) lies in its iterative process. If a candidate secures more than half the first-choice votes, they win, just like in a conventional election. However, if no candidate achieves a majority, the real action begins.
Here’s how it works, step-by-step:
- Elimination: The candidate with the fewest first-choice votes is eliminated.
- Reallocation: Voters who chose the eliminated candidate as their first choice have their votes reallocated to their second-choice candidate.
- Iteration: This process of elimination and reallocation continues until one candidate receives a majority of the votes.
It’s a bit like a series of runoff elections, but all conducted within a single ballot. This ensures the winning candidate has broad support, reflecting the overall preferences of the electorate. this creates fairer election results.
Essentially, ranked-choice voting aims to prevent “spoiler” candidates and wasted votes. This approach gives more say to the voters as they can support their favorite candidates without the worry that doing so might hurt someone they agree with.
The benefits of ranked-choice voting extend beyond simply choosing a winner. The process also offers distinct advantages, as detailed below:
Benefits of ranked-choice Voting
- Increased Voter Choice: Voters can express their preferences freely, supporting their favored candidate without fear of contributing to the election of a less desirable option.
- Reduced Negative Campaigning: Candidates are incentivized to appeal to a broader base of voters, not just their core supporters, since they need to secure second-choice votes.
- More Representative Outcomes: RCV ofen leads to winners who have more widespread support, as the system seeks a candidate with a majority of the vote.
Myths vs. Facts About Ranked-Choice Voting
Like any change to a long-standing system, ranked-choice voting has faced some criticism. Let’s clear up some common misconceptions:
| Myth | Fact |
|---|---|
| Ranked-choice voting is too complex for voters to understand. | Studies have shown that voters quickly grasp the concept and are able to complete their ballots effectively. |
| RCV increases voter error rates. | While there might be a slight increase in initial elections, the process generally proves simple to understand, and any increase in error rate tends to be mitigated as voters become more familiar with the system |
Frequently Asked Questions about Ranked-Choice Voting
To further clarify any remaining questions, here are some frequently asked questions about ranked-choice voting:
Q: Can I only vote for one candidate in a ranked-choice election?
A: No, you can rank as many or as few candidates as you like. It is indeed not required to rank all the candidates to have your vote counted.
Q: What happens if my first-choice candidate is eliminated?
A: Your vote automatically goes to your second-choice candidate, and so on, until one candidate has a majority.
Q: Does ranked-choice voting change how campaigns are run?
A: Yes,candidates may need to broaden their appeal since they are campaigning for second-choice votes.
Q: Is ranked-choice voting used in other places?
A: Yes, besides Maine and Alaska, ranked-choice voting is used in many cities and towns across the United States.
Table of Contents
