Supreme Court Weighs Future of Transgender Athletes, as Youth Voice Fears and Hopes
The US Supreme Court is currently considering cases challenging state laws that ban transgender athletes from participating in school sports, a move that could have sweeping consequences for LGBTQ+ rights across the nation. The cases, brought by transgender students from West Virginia and Idaho, center on bans preventing trans girls from competing on girls’ teams. With 27 states having enacted similar sports bans targeting trans youth, and over 20 states maintaining pro-LGBTQ+ policies, the court’s decision will reverberate far beyond the playing field. As the nation’s highest court deliberates, time.news spoke with five transgender youth and their families about the profound role athletics plays in their lives, and the anxieties they face as their fundamental rights are debated.
A Nation Divided on Transgender Rights in Sports
The debate over transgender athletes in sports has become a flashpoint in the broader culture war, fueled by arguments over fairness, inclusion, and the definition of gender. Opponents of transgender participation often raise concerns about competitive balance, while advocates emphasize the importance of inclusivity and the potential harm caused by discriminatory policies. The current legal battles represent a critical juncture in this ongoing debate, with the potential to either expand or restrict the rights of transgender youth.
“Sports is My Escape” – The Joy and Resilience of Young Athletes
For many young people, sports offer a vital outlet for physical activity, social connection, and personal growth. For transgender youth, the ability to participate in sports aligned with their gender identity can be particularly affirming and empowering. Lina Haaga, a 14-year-old student from Pasadena, California, has been involved in sports since the age of four, participating in soccer, basketball, swimming, water polo, lacrosse, tennis, and track.
“My entire family is very athletic,” Lina explained. “I wasn’t particularly good at soccer, but it helped me realize what an asset sports is in my life – as a release and an escape, but also a way to connect with other people and make new friends.” She described how sports provided a crucial reprieve during stressful times, allowing her to focus on the game or race at hand. However, Lina also expressed growing anxiety about the political climate surrounding transgender athletes.
“The political climate has put into question my relationship with sports,” she said. “Instead of it being something innocent I can just enjoy without fear of being discriminated against, I’ve had to now worry every time I step on the track or the court that somebody might disagree with my participation. That’s been really scary, because it’s started to steal something that’s precious for me – that moment of bliss.” She admitted to sometimes avoiding games out of fear of facing opposition, adding, “Playing sports and loving being out there on the field is in its own beautiful way an act of resistance.” Lina’s message to the Supreme Court was simple: “We’re still human. We’re just kids. We’re just trying to have fun … We’re not trying to be monsters or predators or anything malevolent. We’re just trying to find connection and community.”
Defying the Odds and Inspiring a Movement
The impact of these debates extends beyond individual anxieties, as evidenced by the story of AB Hernandez, a 17-year-old track and field athlete from Jurupa Valley, California. In May, AB achieved a remarkable victory at the California state finals, winning first place in the high jump and triple jump, and silver in the long jump. However, her triumph was overshadowed by targeted attacks from then-President Donald Trump, who publicly questioned her eligibility and even suggested local authorities should prevent her from competing, deeming her participation “TOTALLY DEMEANING TO WOMEN.”
Despite the controversy, AB remained focused on her performance. “Victory meant a lot, especially after all the internet drama,” she said. “To come out on top and be number one. You can’t say anything besides argue with a wall. I’m still competing … Sports is my everything.” AB found strength in the outpouring of support she received, with many people reaching out to express their admiration and solidarity. “People DM’d me to say: ‘I’m so happy you’re fighting. You’re making a really big impact for our community.’ … I thought I just went out and competed, but to others, it was like a movement. I defied the president, in a way. I was like, oh my God, I did do something.” Her mother, Nereyda Hernandez, emphasized the importance of parental support, urging other parents to “support your kids and be louder. We’re unaware of how much support we have within this community until you’re actually put in a position like we were. We’re not alone.”
The Broader Impact: Fear and Uncertainty for Transgender Boys and Families
While much of the focus has been on transgender girls, the anti-trans rhetoric and legislation also create a climate of fear and uncertainty for transgender boys. One 13-year-old transgender boy in the Bay Area, whose name is being withheld to protect his privacy, has been playing soccer since the age of two and now also participates in basketball and baseball. His mother, Jennifer, explained that he struggled to fit in on girls’ teams before coming out as a boy at age nine, but now thrives on boys’ teams.
“If he were barred from athletics due to being trans, we would have to leave the country,” Jennifer stated, expressing her deep concern about the message the country is sending to her son. “The sports issue is so important, because it fundamentally tells us whether people believe trans people exist. Trans girls are girls and belong on girls’ teams. Trans boys are boys and they belong on boys’ teams. Full stop. Once you take the position that trans girls are not girls for the purposes of sports, you have now dehumanized them. It’s a slippery slope to taking away rights after rights after rights.” Her son echoed this sentiment, stating, “I’m just a kid that wants to play sports with my friends. I’m not special. I just want to be left alone and hopefully be successful in sports. We’re not a threat. We’re not gonna tear down the world … If the Trump administration wouldn’t let me play sports, they would basically be taking away part of me.”
Navigating Harassment and Seeking Support
Lily Norcross, a 17-year-old track athlete from California’s central coast, has faced harassment and even death threats as a result of her participation in girls’ sports. “I know this sounds really sad, but I’ve grown used to people calling me slurs,” she said. “The news itself doesn’t bother me as much as what it causes. After Trump was inaugurated, people were far more comfortable openly being transphobic and hating minorities.” Despite the challenges, Lily remains committed to advocating for the rights of transgender youth, recognizing her relative privilege and wanting to support those in less accepting environments. She also expressed frustration with the lack of vocal support from Democratic leaders, feeling they often expect transgender people to fight for themselves. She urged lawmakers to practice empathy: “Put yourself in [our] shoes. Imagine if somebody said your people aren’t allowed to use bathrooms or play sports. How would you feel if you were segregated from everybody else?”
A Sense of Hopelessness and the Fight for Belonging
Leonard, a 17-year-old swimmer and fencer from the Bay Area, expressed a sense of “hopelessness” about the outcome of the Supreme Court case. “I feel hopeless. I don’t like this supreme court and I don’t think they’re going to support trans people’s ability to play sports,” he said, fearing the precedent it could set nationwide. He emphasized the importance of sports in affirming his gender identity, stating, “It made me really, really, really, really happy to be on the boys’ team affirming my gender identity, affirming I was as good as any cis boy. I know that I’m a boy, but being on a boys’ team proves to everyone and myself that I am, in fact, a boy and this is where I’m supposed to be.”
The stories of these five transgender youth underscore the profound impact that sports can have on their lives, providing a sense of community, belonging, and self-affirmation. As the Supreme Court prepares to rule on these critical cases, their voices serve as a powerful reminder of the human cost of discrimination and the fundamental right of all young people to participate fully in society.
Related reading
