Dog Study: Names Don’t Boost Toy Interest, Even in “Gifted” Border Collies

by Priyanka Patel

The canine world is full of surprises, but a growing body of research is highlighting the remarkable cognitive abilities of a select group of dogs known as “gifted word learners.” While most dogs respond to commands, these exceptional animals demonstrate an ability to learn the names of objects – and not just through training. A recent study, published in the journal Animal Cognition, explored whether these dogs, celebrated for their vocabulary skills, show a particular preference for named toys. Surprisingly, the findings suggest that, like many dogs, gifted word learners are simply drawn to the novelty of recent playthings, regardless of whether they’ve learned their names.

Researchers at Eötvös Loránd University (ELU) in Hungary have been at the forefront of this research, spearheaded by co-author Claudia Fugazza. Their operate, part of the ongoing Genius Dog Challenge, builds on previous discoveries that these dogs can not only learn the labels for toys by overhearing their owners, but similarly extend those labels to entirely new objects with similar functions – a skill typically requiring extensive training in other animals. This latest study delves into the motivation behind their interactions with toys, seeking to understand what drives their attention.

The study involved 31 border collies – 10 identified as gifted word learners (GWL) and 21 serving as a control group. Border collies were chosen because they are the most common breed to exhibit this exceptional language ability. Each dog was presented with a selection of eight toys: two that had been previously labeled by their owners, two unlabeled toys, and four entirely new toys. The researchers carefully controlled for scent by washing the toys with soap. Owners familiarized their dogs with the toys over a two-week period, repeatedly naming the labeled toys while presenting them, but remaining silent with the unlabeled ones.

During the testing phase, dogs were given 90-second periods of free access to the toys, observed remotely and recorded for later analysis. The expectation was that the GWL dogs, having learned the names of certain toys, would show a greater interest in those labeled items, mirroring how human babies often gravitate towards objects they’ve heard named. However, the results defied that hypothesis.

Roy is playing with his caretaker.

A. Sommese et al., 2026

“All the dogs, whether they were GWL dogs or not, strongly preferred the new toys,” researchers found, with no significant difference in playtime between labeled and unlabeled items. This suggests that the simple excitement of a novel object is a powerful motivator for dogs, overriding any cognitive advantage gained from knowing a toy’s name. The study challenges the assumption that simply hearing the names of objects automatically increases a dog’s attention to them.

What Drives Canine Curiosity?

This finding doesn’t diminish the remarkable abilities of gifted word learners, but it does offer a nuanced understanding of their motivations. Previous research from Fugazza’s team demonstrated that these dogs can store and recall sensory information about toys – their appearance and smell – when searching for named objects. A study published earlier this month further showed that GWL dogs can even extend learned labels to new objects with similar functions. However, this latest research indicates that novelty remains a primary driver of engagement.

the different toys used during the experiment
The different toys used during the experiment.

A. Sommese et al., 2026

Understanding the cognitive processes of gifted word learner dogs offers insights into the evolution of language and intelligence, not just in canines, but potentially in other species as well. The research team continues to investigate the unique abilities of these dogs, exploring how their exceptional language skills impact their social interactions and problem-solving abilities. The ongoing Genius Dog Challenge is actively recruiting participants, seeking to expand our understanding of these remarkable animals.

The Future of Canine Cognition Research

The ELU team plans to further investigate the social aspects of toy play in gifted word learners. They hypothesize that the dogs’ desire to share toys with their owners may be linked to their advanced cognitive abilities. Future studies will explore whether these dogs exhibit a greater tendency to seek social interaction during playtime, and whether their owners respond differently to their attempts to share. The team is also interested in examining the neural mechanisms underlying these cognitive abilities, using brain imaging techniques to identify the areas of the brain that are most active when the dogs are learning and using language.

The findings from this research, and ongoing studies like it, contribute to a growing understanding of canine intelligence and the complex relationship between humans and their companions. As we continue to unravel the mysteries of the canine mind, we gain a deeper appreciation for the remarkable abilities of these animals and the unique bond we share with them. The next phase of the Genius Dog Challenge will focus on analyzing data from a larger cohort of dogs, aiming to identify the genetic and environmental factors that contribute to the development of gifted word learning abilities.

What do you reckon about these clever canines? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and be sure to share this article with fellow dog lovers!

You may also like

Leave a Comment