A cloud of uncertainty surrounding the future of the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) and broader U.S. Trade policy is actively discouraging investment across North America, according to a prominent Canadian business leader. The hesitation to commit capital is impacting economic growth in all three countries, raising concerns about a potential slowdown as the agreement’s review period approaches.
Shauna Hemingway, who previously served as the deputy head of mission at the Canadian embassy in Mexico City, articulated these concerns, stating that Canadian businesses are prioritizing “certainty, stability and predictability” in their economic relationship with the United States. The U.S. Remains Canada’s largest trading partner, accounting for roughly 75.4% of Canadian exports in December 2023. Hemingway’s warning underscores a growing anxiety that shifting political winds in Washington could jeopardize the hard-won stability provided by the USMCA.
The USMCA, which replaced the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 2020, was intended to modernize trade rules and strengthen economic ties between the three nations. However, the agreement includes a review clause every six years, beginning in 2026, which allows for potential modifications or even termination. This looming review, coupled with the unpredictable nature of U.S. Trade policy under the current administration, is creating a climate of apprehension among investors. The Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) is responsible for leading the USMCA review process, and its priorities will be crucial in shaping the future of the agreement. More information about the USMCA can be found on the USTR website.
Investment Decisions on Hold
The impact of this uncertainty isn’t limited to Canada. Businesses in Mexico and the United States are also reportedly delaying major investment decisions. Companies are hesitant to launch new projects or expand existing operations when the rules of the game could change significantly in the near future. This hesitancy affects a wide range of sectors, including automotive, manufacturing, and agriculture – all heavily reliant on cross-border trade.
“We’re seeing a real chill effect,” explained a senior economist at a major Canadian bank, speaking on background. “Companies are taking a ‘wait-and-see’ approach. They’re holding onto capital, waiting for more clarity before making long-term commitments.” The economist noted that this reluctance to invest is particularly concerning given the current economic climate, with global growth slowing and inflation remaining stubbornly high.
The automotive industry, a cornerstone of North American manufacturing, is particularly vulnerable. The USMCA includes stringent rules of origin for automobiles, requiring a significant percentage of vehicle content to be produced within the region. Any changes to these rules could disrupt supply chains and increase costs for automakers. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety provides an overview of the USMCA’s impact on the automotive industry.
Beyond the Review: Broader Trade Concerns
The anxiety extends beyond the scheduled USMCA review. Recent U.S. Trade actions, including tariffs on certain goods and a more protectionist rhetoric, have added to the uncertainty. Businesses are worried that the U.S. Could impose new trade barriers at any time, disrupting established supply chains and increasing costs. This concern is particularly acute for Canadian businesses, which are heavily reliant on access to the U.S. Market.
The potential for the re-imposition of tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum, previously lifted under the USMCA, is a specific worry. Such a move would not only harm the Canadian steel and aluminum industries but also disrupt supply chains for manufacturers in both Canada and the United States. The Canadian Steel Producers Association has consistently advocated for a stable and predictable trade environment.
Stakeholders Expressing Concern
Several key stakeholders have voiced their concerns about the growing trade uncertainty:
- Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters (CME): The CME has called on the Canadian government to work with the U.S. To ensure the stability of the USMCA and to address concerns about potential trade barriers.
- U.S. Chamber of Commerce: The Chamber has emphasized the importance of maintaining a free and open trading relationship with Canada and Mexico, arguing that it is essential for U.S. Economic growth.
- Mexican Business Council (Consejo Mexicano de Negocios): The Council has expressed concerns about the potential for U.S. Trade policies to disrupt Mexican exports and investment.
What’s Next for USMCA?
The next major checkpoint for the USMCA is the July 1, 2026, review. Prior to that date, however, there are several key developments to watch. The U.S. Presidential election in November 2024 will have a significant impact on the future of U.S. Trade policy. A change in administration could lead to a major shift in approach to the USMCA and trade relations with Canada and Mexico. Ongoing negotiations on specific trade issues, such as energy and digital trade, could influence the overall stability of the agreement.
The USTR is expected to release a report on the implementation of the USMCA in early 2025, which will provide an assessment of the agreement’s performance and identify areas for potential improvement. This report will be a crucial input into the 2026 review process. Businesses across North America will be closely watching these developments, hoping for a clear signal that the USMCA will remain a stable and predictable framework for trade and investment.
Disclaimer: This article provides information for general knowledge and informational purposes only, and does not constitute financial or legal advice.
The current climate of uncertainty underscores the interconnectedness of the North American economies and the importance of a stable trade environment. What are your thoughts on the future of USMCA? Share your comments below and let us know how these developments are impacting your business or industry.
Keep reading
