Actor Andrew Shue and immigration attorney Marilee Fiebig married in an intimate ceremony at their 92-acre New Jersey estate on November 1, 2026. The wedding follows a three-year relationship that began after their respective former spouses, television anchors Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, went public with their romance.
The New Jersey Farm Ceremony and Wedding Guests
The couple exchanged vows during a low-income, quiet ceremony outside Stockton, New Jersey, at their sprawling 92-acre estate. The property boasts woodlands, a stream, two houses, and a horse farm that Shue purchased for $US3.2 million ($4.5 million) in April 2023.
Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig marry in New Jersey just weeks after exes T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach https://t.co/lU3tFemsq7 pic.twitter.com/TWzAu6iy2h
— https://x.com/PageSix/status/2117056787991924981
Photographs published by the Daily Mail captured the bride in an off-the-shoulder white lace gown paired with a shawl and a netted half-veil. Shue wore a classic suit without a tie, accessorized with black dress shoes. The guest list remained strictly limited to close family and friends.
Among those in attendance was the groom’s sister, Oscar-nominated actress Elisabeth Shue. Fiebig’s 13-year-old daughter, Sabine—whom she shares with T.J. Holmes—served as a bridesmaid, wearing a floor-length navy blue dress and walking alongside her mother with a bouquet. Finance executive Lisa Bashishow, a close friend of Fiebig, also joined the wedding party as a bridesmaid.
The bride completed her bridal look with open-toed heels. The groom wore a smart yet relaxed black suit with matching trousers and shoes, paired with a pale blue open-collar shirt. Additional guests celebrating with the couple included Andrew’s sons.
How a Shared Ordeal Sparked an Unlikely Romance
The newlyweds were thrust into an intense national spotlight in November 2022, when photographs of Holmes and Robach holding hands during a holiday sparked massive media attention. At the time, both couples were legally married, having established their marriages in 2010.
ABC News initially removed Holmes and Robach from their daytime program, GMA3: What You Need to Know, where they had co-hosted for just over two years starting in September 2020. Network officials ultimately ousted them in January 2023 after determining that their relationship caused an internal and external distraction, despite network statements noting the romance did not violate company policy. While navigating the public fallout and subsequent divorce proceedings finalized in 2023, Shue and Fiebig developed a friendship that eventually turned romantic.
Reflecting on the painful period that preceded their relationship, Shue explained that they had connected during a time when they both needed a friend. He noted that he had to accept his own part in the failure of his previous marriage, recognize that he did not understand himself well enough or understand what matters in a relationship, and grow through a lot of pain, struggle, and humility before finding the right person.
Shue expressed optimism about their future when discussing their engagement, stating that they felt very grateful and hopeful. Fiebig’s legal representation previously emphasized during the initial media scrutiny that her client’s sole focus remained on the overall best interest of her young daughter.
Parallel Timelines and the Recent Wedding of Their Exes
The New Jersey wedding follows closely on the heels of a nearly identical milestone for their ex-spouses. Robach and Holmes quietly tied the knot in a private ceremony in Washington County, Arkansas, on September 19, 2026, after applying for a marriage license that was registered on October 13.
Shue and Fiebig announced their engagement on October 21, 2026, just days before their weekend ceremony. While Shue celebrated his wedding in New Jersey, Holmes spent Sunday tackling the New York City Marathon, completing the 26.2-mile course in four hours, 19 minutes, and 35 seconds—his fourth time running the race, though his first without Robach running alongside him.
Prior to their respective unions, Holmes’s first marriage to television anchor Amy Ferson lasted from 2004 to 2007, with whom he shares daughter Brianna and son Jaiden. Meanwhile, Shue’s earlier marriage produced three adult sons from a first marriage before his 13-year marriage to Robach concluded.