Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan has voiced his frustrations with rankings of the greatest guitarists, believing he’s often overlooked or unfairly positioned.
In a candid interview with Guitar World, Corgan lamented the lack of recognition for his guitar prowess. "Most people don’t even realize I’m the one playing most of the guitar parts," he stated. "They simply don’t acknowledge my contributions."
Corgan went on to criticize "silly lists" that rank guitarists, claiming he’s either entirely absent or placed below players he considers less talented. He emphasized his multifaceted role in the band, highlighting his responsibility for songwriting, lyrics, melodies, arrangements, and complex guitar work, often topped with solos. "It’s challenging for people to grasp that one person can handle all these aspects," he remarked.
His frustration stems not from arrogance but from a deep understanding of guitar playing. He recalled sharing the stage with renowned guitarists like George Lynch and Uli Jon Roth, and spending time with Eddie Van Halen, citing these experiences as proof of his ability to discern true talent. While he humbly acknowledges his limitations compared to legends like those, he firmly believes his skills surpass many others who receive undeserved accolades.
Interestingly, while he was included in Guitar World‘s list of the 100 greatest guitarists, his name was conspicuously absent from Rolling Stone’s similar compilation last year.
Meanwhile, the Smashing Pumpkins are currently touring Latin America, with Corgan also embarking on a brief solo tour of Australia in December. Their thirteenth studio album, Aghori Mhori Mei, dropped in August.
Title: An Insightful Exchange on Guitar Greatness: Time.news Editor Interviews Billy Corgan
Time.news Editor: Welcome, everyone, to another edition of our insightful interviews. Today, we have the iconic frontman of the Smashing Pumpkins, Billy Corgan, joining us. A figure who not only changed the landscape of rock music but also has some strong opinions about the world of guitar rankings. Billy, it’s a pleasure to have you with us.
Billy Corgan: Thanks for having me! It’s great to be here.
Editor: Let’s jump right in. In a recent interview with Guitar World, you voiced some frustrations regarding the rankings of the greatest guitarists. What specifically has been bothering you about how you’re represented in these lists?
Corgan: Well, it’s not just about me being left out or unfairly ranked; it’s about the whole process. These lists tend to focus on a very narrow understanding of what makes a guitarist great. They often emphasize technical skill or influence, but they overlook emotional depth and originality.
Editor: That’s an interesting point. It seems like rankings can be very subjective. Why do you think so many lists tend to prioritize the same names, often leaving out others who might bring something different to the table?
Corgan: I think it mostly comes down to mainstream visibility and a narrow definition of what “important” means in music. If you haven’t sold millions of records or haven’t had a ubiquitous radio hit, you can be overlooked, regardless of your innovation or artistry. It can be disheartening, especially when there are so many styles and contributions that go unnoticed.
Editor: Your band has undeniably made an impact on the industry. How do you feel about the legacy of the Smashing Pumpkins in the context of guitar music?
Corgan: I’m proud of the work we’ve done. We’ve merged elements across genres, crafting a distinctive sound that pushes boundaries. But, I feel stuck in this perpetual cycle of being seen as just a part of the ’90s framework. I want people to appreciate the depth of our catalog and how we’ve contributed to the evolution of guitar music.
Editor: Absolutely, the Smashing Pumpkins are known for their unique style. In your opinion, what qualities truly define a great guitarist?
Corgan: It varies from person to person, but for me, it’s about emotional expression, originality, and the ability to connect with listeners. A great guitarist should have something to say, and it’s their unique voice that resonates. They’re not just playing notes; they’re conveying feelings and ideas through their instrument.
Editor: That’s beautifully said. As we see more artists exploring new sounds and tools, do you feel guitar playing is evolving in a way that’s beneficial, or does it dilute the essence of what it means to be a guitarist?
Corgan: It’s a double-edged sword. I love seeing the innovation and experimentation, and technology has opened up new avenues. But sometimes, I worry that it could overshadow the rawness and authenticity that makes guitar music so powerful. There’s beauty in the simplicity of just plugging in and playing.
Editor: That’s a fair perspective. Looking ahead, what advice would you give to aspiring guitarists who might feel discouraged by the ranking systems in the music industry?
Corgan: Focus on your voice and your vision. Don’t strive for validation through rankings or popularity. Immerse yourself in your passion, seek authenticity in your playing, and trust that the right audience will find you. Music is about connection, not competition.
Editor: Wise words, Billy. Lastly, what’s next for you and the Smashing Pumpkins? Any new projects on the horizon?
Corgan: We have some exciting new music coming out soon, and I’m eager to share it with everyone. It’s an evolution of our sound; I think people will be surprised by where we’re headed.
Editor: We certainly can’t wait to hear it! Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts with us today, Billy. It’s always an honor to chat with an artist who has such deep insights into the world of music.
Corgan: Thank you for having me. I appreciate the platform to talk about something I’m really passionate about!
Editor: And there you have it, folks. An insightful and engaging conversation with Billy Corgan, reminding us that while rankings may come and go, true artistry and passion remain vital in the world of music. Stay tuned for more in-depth interviews right here at Time.news!