“You guys, politicians, are all the same,” said Billy, an undecided voter, at the News24 and Herald Sun People’s Forum on Tuesday night.
One hundred undecided voters packed into the Sofitel in Melbourne on Tuesday night for the only leaders’ debate of the 2026 Victorian election campaign. News24 Chief News Anchor Kieran Gilbert hosted it.
The 90-minute forum brought together Labor Premier Ben Carroll, Liberal Leader Jess Wilson, Greens Leader Ellen Sandell, and One Nation Victorian Leader Warren Pickering.
Early voting opens on Wednesday.
The event aired at 7.30 pm AEDT and streamed across multiple platforms, including News24, Herald Sun, Foxtel, BINGE, News24 Regional, and the FAST channel News24 Now. This confrontation preceded election day on Saturday, November 28, following weeks of prior disagreements over debate formats that caused Carroll to withdraw from a separate Channel Nine event.
Carroll Defends Labor Debt Record and CFMEU Royal Commission
Victoria’s net debt is projected to nudge $200 billion by 2030.
Carroll defended Labor’s record by pointing to $2 billion in savings identified on delayed and trimmed infrastructure projects. He said debt couldn’t be viewed in isolation after 12 years of Labor administration and pointed to physical assets accrued.
Carroll pointed to his decision to call a royal commission into the CFMEU and the Big Build. He engaged immediately with the police commissioner and tackled the cost of living. He challenged Wilson’s promise of achieving a cash surplus by 2032 by citing research suggesting her plan would require $40 billion in cuts.
Wilson rejected those claims, stating that only the Liberal and Nationals possess a concrete plan to balance the budget in the state. “I won’t be lectured by you or your government on costings when you have racked up $200bn worth of debt in this state,” Wilson told Carroll, as reported by the Guardian.
When Carroll dismissed her attacks, Wilson countered that his assertions were simply “desperate lies and a scare campaign” and declared that Victorians had grown tired of it.
The legacy of past administrations hung over the proceedings. The Premier was pressed about the previous governments led by Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan. Carroll said that he could say their names just as easily as his opponent refused to utter that of former Victorian premier Jeff Kennett.
Wilson fired back, “Jeff Kennett,” prompting immediate laughter from the audience. Opposition Leader Jess Wilson chimed in to encourage him to name Andrews directly, noting he was not Voldemort.
On public safety, One Nation Victorian Leader Warren Pickering delivered a blistering assessment. He compared Melbourne to “Gotham City from Batman” due to rising crime.

Pickering vowed to lock up offenders even if it meant sending them interstate to new supermax facilities opening in New South Wales. Wilson agreed with the sentiment.
Wilson argued that perpetrators laugh at authorities because they know they will be released on bail by the end of a shift. She labeled it a direct consequence of Labor weakening the state’s bail laws.
The debate also featured sharp exchanges over protests in Melbourne’s central business district. Wilson pledged to introduce a permit system for public demonstrations to curb ongoing disruptions, asking Carroll why such protests had continued unchecked under his watch.
Sandell defended the right to peaceful protest, drawing a sharp distinction between unacceptable antisemitism and citizens speaking out against military actions by the government of Israel. Wilson countered that these demonstrations had seen participants throw rocks.
Audience Poll Results
When the 100 undecided voters were polled as they left the Sofitel, Wilson emerged as the clear winner of the forum.
| Leader | Audience Share |
|---|---|
| Jess Wilson | 39 per cent |
| Ellen Sandell | 25 per cent |
| Warren Pickering | 16 per cent |
| Ben Carroll | 7 per cent |
| Undecided | 13 per cent |
Early voting centres open across Victoria on Wednesday ahead of election day on November 28. Polling shows the coalition leading Labor, according to a survey published in the Australian Financial Review.
Recent surveys published in the Australian Financial Review indicated the Coalition sitting at 31 per cent of the vote ahead of Labor’s 23 per cent. One Nation sat at 22 per cent and the Greens at 15 per cent.
“Jeff Kennett,” Wilson said.