2024-05-27 20:56:09
Ought to 12-year-old criminals be punished? It is not simply politicians who’re arguing about this query; our readers are additionally divided.
The worrying enhance in juvenile crime has led Carsten Linnemann, Secretary Normal of the CDU, to need to decrease the age of prison accountability from 14 to 12. You may learn his visitor article right here.
The 46-year-old’s initiative led to optimistic and unfavourable reactions from quite a few politicians. Some representatives of the visitors gentle coalition criticized him sharply. There’s additionally a heated debate amongst t-online readers about whether or not 12-year-olds also needs to be prosecuted.
“Motion should be taken”
Frank Peters writes: “I completely agree with Mr Linnemann and the CDU. When you think about that crime amongst kids is changing into increasingly frequent, motion should be taken. On the identical time, juvenile prison legislation must be utilized constantly from the age of 18. In critical prison instances, jail sentences should even be thought of. Solely this creates deterrence, and over time, extra safety and a discount in crime.”
“My a few years {of professional} exercise in and with households, well being and youth welfare places of work in addition to youth courtroom help have proven me that there’s a lack of certified employees in all areas,” studies Petronella WöllnerThere must be no additional financial savings in these areas, as this is able to solely exacerbate the issue. “The twisted thought of decreasing the age of prison accountability doesn’t assist.”
“The cuddly pedagogy shouldn’t be adequate”
Silvia mails: “The cuddly pedagogy and the anti-authoritarian parenting fashion of the post-1968 technology shouldn’t be adequate. Youngsters spend most of their time within the nucleus of society, the households, and obtain their values or not, earlier than they turn into rowdy schoolchildren.”
In response to the t-online reader, the extent of psychological maturity, which should now be the topic of complete research, should be taken into consideration when figuring out prison accountability. “As a result of our world right this moment is not the world it as soon as was when the age of prison accountability was initially set.”
“Mother and father should educate kids, not prisons”
“The CDU is simply fishing within the AfD swamp for votes from dissident voters,” suspects Walter Graf“It’s election season and it’s greater than regrettable that this celebration can solely give you populist statements.”
In his opinion, prison accountability at 12 years of age could be ineffective. “Mother and father should educate kids, not courts and prisons.” The t-online reader believes it might be useful if there was a ban on cell telephones in faculties and a normal ban on TikTok.
“Toddlers at major faculty degree”
“These kids could typically look like precocious of their bodily improvement, however mentally they’re typically toddlers at preschool or elementary faculty degree,” claims Dr. med. Matthias Comp“This stunning reality is sadly not acknowledged to the mandatory extent in our society, that bodily maturation is confused with a state of psychological maturity.”
This psychological infantility can typically be seen within the mother and father of those kids, says the t-online reader, who doesn’t advocate decreasing the age to 12. As an alternative, grownup prison legislation ought to apply totally to 18-year-olds, however mixed with complete maturation measures. “Not in common prisons and never in establishments the place these younger adults are gathered. As a result of group detention will increase or promotes regression, immaturity and lack of improvement in a disastrous manner. Solely particular person help might help right here, as a result of improvement is never profitable within the mass of unruly kids.”