CIOs Confront IT Skills Shortage: Is ‘Hiring for Attitude’ the Answer?
As critical IT positions remain unfilled and the threat of AI-driven job displacement looms, industry leaders are questioning traditional hiring practices and exploring whether prioritizing attitude over immediate skill sets could be a viable solution.
The IT job market is grappling with persistent skills shortages, a challenge compounded by anxieties surrounding the potential for artificial intelligence to automate entry-level roles. This has prompted a reevaluation of recruitment strategies, with some CIOs considering a shift towards “hiring for attitude” – prioritizing candidates with strong work ethic and a willingness to learn. As one former CIO explained, seeking out individuals with a positive, “can-do” approach and a desire to succeed is paramount.
The Rising Cost of IT Talent
Finding and retaining skilled IT professionals is becoming increasingly difficult and expensive. Currently, it takes an average of 41 days to fill an IT position and 62 days to hire an engineer, starting from the job posting to the employee’s first day. However, these timelines can stretch to months, even years, for specialized roles like data scientists, senior systems programmers, database administrators, and Chief Information Security Officers (CISOs).
The high demand for talent is also driving up turnover rates. Technology workers are projected to experience a turnover rate of 20-25% in 2025 – the highest across all industry sectors. Replacing these employees is costly, with expenses ranging from half to four times the departing employee’s annual salary. These factors are leading CIOs to explore alternative strategies, including investing in internal talent development.
Can Attitude Bridge the Skills Gap?
While “hiring for attitude” won’t instantly solve the IT skills shortage, it can be a valuable component of a broader strategy. Experts acknowledge that seasoned professionals – senior database analysts, software engineers, and network and security specialists – typically require five to six years of experience to hone their expertise. Intermediate-level staff have three to four years under their belts, while junior employees average six months to two years.
The key lies in identifying individuals with the potential to learn quickly and contribute positively to a team. A “diamond in the rough” may initially lack specific skills, but a strong attitude and aptitude for learning can be invaluable. One example cited involved a less-skilled but highly motivated junior employee successfully taking over a critical technical role when a more experienced colleague lacked engagement.
Three Strategies for Cultivating Attitude-Driven Talent
Successfully implementing a strategy of “hiring for attitude” requires a deliberate and multifaceted approach. Here are three key strategies:
-
Refine Talent Prospecting: Identifying potential requires looking beyond traditional qualifications. IT leaders should seek candidates who demonstrate both a “can-do” attitude and a natural ability to quickly grasp new concepts. A junior maintenance programmer who independently develops automated robots in their spare time, for instance, might be a strong candidate for a factory automation role.
-
Prioritize Training and Development: Simply finding enthusiastic employees isn’t enough. Organizations must invest in fostering and developing their potential. While seminars and certifications have value, real-world project experience is crucial for building confidence and applying learned skills. This requires aligning project assignments with skills development goals and ensuring senior staff are committed to mentoring junior colleagues. However, CIOs must first assess the willingness and ability of their senior technical staff to effectively train and mentor.
-
Assign Real-World Projects: Providing junior staff with meaningful project assignments is the most effective way for them to “cut their teeth” and gain practical experience. This hands-on approach allows them to learn from mistakes, build confidence, and develop essential skills.
Ultimately, “hiring for attitude” is a complementary strategy, not a replacement for recruiting experienced professionals. A blended approach – continuing to hire top talent while simultaneously transforming raw talent within the organization – offers the most promising path forward. This multifaceted strategy allows IT departments to better adapt to the rapid pace of technological advancement and ensure they have the skills needed to meet future challenges.
