Title: San Francisco Giants Part Ways with Gabe Kapler as Manager following Disappointing Season
Subtitle: The Giants search for stability continues after firing Kapler, who had one year remaining on his contract
SAN FRANCISCO — In a surprising move, the San Francisco Giants have fired Gabe Kapler, their manager for the past two years. Despite being named National League Manager of the Year in 2022, Kapler’s tenure with the Giants has been marked by inconsistent performance and a lack of success in the playoffs.
The Giants had high hopes when they hired Kapler before the 2019 season, but their postseason drought continued as they missed the playoffs in three of his four years in charge. The exception was in 2021 when the Giants won 107 games and secured the division title. However, they failed to build on that success, finishing 81-81 the following season and collapsing in the second half of this year’s campaign.
With just one week remaining in the season, the Giants find themselves in fourth place in the NL West with a record of 78-81. The final two months proved to be disastrous, leading to the decision to let Kapler go. Some players publicly expressed their concerns about the organization’s preparation, energy, and commitment to building a winning culture.
The team’s performance plummeted in the second half, especially on the road, where they struggled to win crucial games. Their offense has been the worst in baseball since July, and defensive errors have become a frequent occurrence. Despite strong pitching, the Giants were hindered by a lack of reliable starters.
Even with a promising start to September, the Giants recorded a dismal 8-17 record during the month, jeopardizing their chances of reaching .500. The widespread belief that a change in clubhouse culture was necessary further fueled the decision to let Kapler go.
This is not the first time Kapler has been let go under similar circumstances. He was fired by the Philadelphia Phillies after just two seasons for failing to meet expectations and connect with the players. Several criticisms emerged, including an overreliance on analytics and a failure to hold players accountable.
Moreover, Kapler struggled to connect with the Giants’ fan base, and his tenure lacked the resonance that the previous regime had achieved. The decision to fire him was not made lightly, as the Giants look to bring in a new manager who can reignite enthusiasm both within the team and among supporters.
For Kapler, it marks his second firing in four years, while for the Giants, it is their second managerial search since Farhan Zaidi took over as President of Baseball Operations. Zaidi, who handpicked Kapler as his first choice to replace the legendary Bruce Bochy, is now facing the pressure to find a long-term solution with the knowledge that he may not get another opportunity.
As the Giants embark on another managerial search, the focus now shifts to finding a leader who can bring stability and success to a franchise hungry for a return to postseason glory.
[Download and Follow the Giants Talk Podcast]