Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were eliminated from the “Dancing with the Stars” semifinals on Tuesday, Nov. 17, despite earning two perfect scores during the episode.
The departure of the Glee actor and his partner came as a surprise to the judges, as the pair finished the night tied for the top of the leaderboard with a perfect 60 out of 60. While Shum Jr. and Johnson performed at the highest level, they were sent home one week before the season 35 finale after failing to secure enough viewer votes to overcome the other top-scoring contestants.
The elimination follows a period of significant turnover in the competition. TVLine reported that the show had already seen the unexpected exit of Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy during the previous week’s quarterfinals.
Judges react to high scores
The semifinal round required the six remaining couples to perform one ballroom routine and one Latin routine. Shum Jr. opened his night with a paso doble to “We Found Love” by Rihanna featuring Calvin Harris, which earned a perfect 30 out of 30. Deadline reported that Carrie Ann Inaba called the performance “the paso doble of the season!”
For his second dance, Shum Jr. performed a quickstep to “Valerie” by Mark Ronson featuring Amy Winehouse, earning another perfect score. The Hollywood Reporter noted that this second perfect score tied the pair with Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov at the top of the leaderboard.
The judges offered significant praise for the quickstep. People reported that Bruno Tonioli described the performance as “out of this world!”
“That is how you quickstep into the finals right there,” said Derek Hough, according to TV Grapevine.
High scores determine semifinal results
The night was characterized by high scores across the field, with several couples achieving near-perfect marks. While Shum Jr. and Glenn led the scoring, the final results were determined by a combination of judges’ points and audience votes.
| Contestant and Partner | Total Score | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson | 60/60 | Eliminated |
| Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov | 60/60 | Safe |
| Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas | 59/60 | Safe |
| Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach | 57/60 | Safe |
| Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik | 55/60 | Safe |
| Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold | 48/60 | Safe |
Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas achieved a total score of 59. According to Us Weekly, the pair earned a 29/30 for their Viennese waltz and a perfect 30/30 for their samba to “Samba Vocalizado” by Luciano Perrone. Derek Hough described the samba as “beautifully satisfying,” while Bruno Tonioli called it “saucy.” Higgins told her partner the competition was the “” she had done.
Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov also secured a perfect 60/60. Their night included a salsa to “Bemba Colorá” by Celia Cruz, which earned them 30/30.
Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach earned a total of 57/60. For their first dance, the pair performed a quickstep to “Kryptonite” by 3 Doors Down, receiving a score of 27/30. Bruno Tonioli noted the performance was “solid as a rock,” though he advised the pair to “watch the frame.” During the quickstep, Bruno Tonioli called out Ezra Frech’s frame, while Derek Hough called the Paralympian the definition of defying the odds.

Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik finished with 55/60. Ali danced a waltz to “Open Arms” by Journey for a score of 27/30. She also performed a cha-cha to “I Like It Like That” by Pete Rodríguez, earning 28/30. Carrie Ann Inaba said that despite having the lowest scores of all semi-finalists, Ali’s performance made everyone “believe we can.”
Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold earned a total of 48/60. The comedian and podcaster performed a jive to “Blue Suede Shoes” by Elvis Presley for a score of 24/30, followed by a quickstep to “Dance, Dance” by Fall Out Boy, which also earned 24/30.
As the final contestants were announced, People reported that Carrie Ann Inaba was visibly shocked when the hosts revealed that Shum Jr. and Johnson were the pair being sent home.
Theories on the elimination
Following the elimination, co-host Julianne Hough shared her perspective on why a high-scoring couple might exit the competition. E! News reported that Hough suggested voting patterns might be influenced by the strength of the scores.
“Sometimes when people are doing so well in the competition, people don’t necessarily vote,” Hough told the duo, “because they think you’re doing so well with scores.”
Upcoming finale schedule
The competition moves into its final stage next week. Sports Illustrated Lifestyle reported that the special three-hour finale is scheduled to air on ABC on Tuesday, Nov. 24, at 8 p.m. ET.
Details for the Season 35 finale
What can viewers expect from the final episode of “Dancing with the Stars”?
The finale will feature the remaining five couples competing in three separate routines, including a judges’ choice round, an instant dance, and a freestyle routine, according to TODAY.
More on Jenna Johnson
Come on over and watch Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson nail their #SemiFinals Quickstep! 🌟 #DWTS pic.twitter.com/wuHbU2IVSt