Meaningful rise in Ireland‘s Dual-Use Exports to Israel Amid Ongoing Conflict
Table of Contents
- Meaningful rise in Ireland’s Dual-Use Exports to Israel Amid Ongoing Conflict
Since October 2023, ireland has exported over €97 million in dual-use products to Israel, as confirmed by the Department of Enterprise. This surge in exports comes in the wake of escalating tensions following the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, which prompted a considerable Israeli military response in Gaza.
Understanding Dual-Use Products
Dual-use items are defined as products that can serve both civilian and military purposes. These exports require a special license before they can leave Ireland, ensuring that they are not misused.
Official Confirmation and Licensing Details
Minister of State Niamh Smyth disclosed in the Dáil that a total of 42 licenses have been issued for these exports. “Most dual-use exports are mainstream business ICT products, both hardware and software, networking, data-storage, and cyber-security,” she explained to Sinn Féin TD Cathy Bennett.
Concerns Over Export Practices
Deputy Bennett raised concerns about the dramatic increase in exports as the onset of conflict, questioning whether this trend is “suspect” given the current struggles of the Israeli economy. In contrast,the total value of dual-use exports in 2022 was only €10.7 million.
Government Accountability and Oversight
Highlighting the government’s involvement, Deputy Bennett noted that Ireland has intervened in a case at the International Court of Justice concerning allegations of genocide against Israel.She questioned whether the Irish government bears obligation for ensuring that no components exported could possibly contribute to war crimes.
“We are sure we have very strong controls in place,” Minister Smyth responded, emphasizing that a “robust risk assessment” process is conducted for all exports.
Ongoing Scrutiny and Future Licensing
Independent TD Catherine Connolly expressed her dissatisfaction with the information provided, seeking clarity on how many export applications have been denied and the rationale behind those decisions. In response, Minister Smyth offered to arrange a meeting between her officials and the concerned deputies to address these “legitimate” issues.
Recent Licensing Statistics
As of the first quarter of 2025, three licenses have been issued, amounting to “just under €427,000.” Below is a detailed breakdown of the licensing activity for the latter half of 2023 and throughout 2024:
2023 Licensing Breakdown
- Q3: Seven licenses issued worth €1.14 million
- Q4: Three licenses issued worth €31.24 million
2024 licensing Breakdown
- Q1: Seven licenses issued worth €1.18 million
- Q2: Ten licenses issued worth €20.59 million
- Q3: Six licenses issued worth €8.57 million
- Q4: Six licenses issued worth €33.93 million
Total Exports
The cumulative total of dual-use exports from Ireland to israel since October 2023 stands at €97,077,000.
Ireland’s dual-Use Exports to Israel: An Expert’s Perspective
Time.news Editor: Welcome, readers. Today, we’re diving into a concerning trend: the significant rise in Ireland’s dual-use exports to Israel as October 2023. To help us unpack this complex issue, we have Dr.Eleanor Vance, an expert in international trade adn security.Dr. Vance,thank you for joining us.
Dr. Eleanor Vance: it’s my pleasure to be here.
Time.news Editor: Dr.Vance, for our readers who may not be familiar, can you explain what “dual-use” products are and why their export is so closely monitored?
Dr. eleanor Vance: Certainly. Dual-use products are goods,technologies,and software that can be used for both civilian and military applications.Think of high-powered computers, advanced networking equipment, or specific chemicals. Their export is closely monitored as, while they can be used for legitimate purposes, they could also be diverted to military or weapons programs. This is why these products require specific export licenses from authorities.
Time.news editor: According to recent reports, Ireland’s dual-use exports to israel have surged dramatically as October 2023, reaching over €97 million. This follows the Hamas attack and the subsequent Israeli military response. What’s your take on this significant increase?
Dr. Eleanor Vance: The spike is definitely noteworthy.A jump from €10.7 million in 2022 to over €97 million is substantial and warrants close scrutiny. The timing coinciding with escalating conflict raises legitimate questions about the end-use of these exports and whether they are inadvertently contributing to the conflict. The types of dual-use exports, mainly ICT like hardware, software, and cybersecurity tools raise questions about if they are being used in intelligence gathering, weapons systems, or other military applications.
Time.news Editor: The Irish government insists that robust risk assessments are in place for all exports. Though,concerns have been raised,particularly by Deputy bennett,about the potential for these products to contribute to war crimes,given Ireland’s intervention in the International Court of Justice case. How should governments balance trade interests with ethical considerations in situations like this?
Dr. eleanor Vance: It’s a delicate balancing act. Governments have a responsibility to support their domestic industries and facilitate trade.However, that responsibility cannot come at the expense of upholding international law and ethical principles. Robust risk assessments are crucial, but they need to be more than just a formality. They need to be obvious, rigorous, and take into account the specific context of the conflict. Factors of diversion,current economic struggles of the destination economy must be a part of this process. The ultimate question is: what can we do to ensure ICT products are not being funneled into malicious activity in Israel and Gaza?
Time.news Editor: Minister Smyth has offered a meeting with officials to address these concerns. Independent TD Catherine Connolly is seeking clarity on the number of denied export applications and the reasons behind those decisions. How significant is clarity in this process?
Dr. Eleanor Vance: Transparency is paramount. Public access to information about export licensing decisions is essential for accountability. Knowing how many applications are denied, the reasons for denial, and the criteria used in the risk assessment process allows for informed public debate and helps ensure that the system is functioning as intended. It also helps to build public trust, which is crucial in such sensitive situations.
Time.news Editor: What advice would you give to individuals or companies involved in the export of dual-use items to ensure they are acting responsibly?
Dr. Eleanor Vance: Firstly, strict adherence to export control regulations is essential. Ignorance is not an excuse.Secondly, conduct thorough due diligence on your customers and end-users. Know who you are dealing with and what the intended use of your products is. Red flags, such as unusually large orders or customers with a history of diversion, should be taken seriously. Thirdly, consider implementing internal ethics programs and training to raise awareness among employees about the risks associated with dual-use exports. engage with government authorities and industry associations to stay informed about best practices and evolving regulations.
Time.news Editor: The licensing breakdown shows significant fluctuations across quarters. Is that normal and are there specific implications for these fluctuations?
Dr. Eleanor Vance: Fluctuations can occur due to several factors, including changing market demands and specific business operations. Though, significant spikes, like the Q4 2023 exports, require deeper inspection as they can be indicators of either a surge in demand for legitimate use, or an increased need driven by conflict. consistent monitoring and clarification on why certain quarters witness higher activity is crucial for transparency and ensuring there are no diversions for military use.
Time.news Editor: Thank you,Dr. Vance, for your valuable insights. This is certainly a complex and evolving issue, and your expertise has been instrumental in shedding light on the key considerations.
Dr. Eleanor Vance: Thank you for having me.
Time.news Editor: Readers, stay tuned to Time.news for further updates on this developing story.We encourage you to stay informed and engage in thoughtful discussions about the ethical implications of international trade and conflict.
