Age Discrimination Claim Looms as Government Mandates Eye Tests for Older Drivers
Table of Contents
A new policy requiring drivers over 70 to undergo regular vision tests to retain their licenses is facing legal challenges, with campaigners alleging age discrimination. The proposed rules, part of a broader government strategy to improve road safety, have sparked outrage and accusations of unfairly targeting older motorists.
The UK government, led by Keir Starmer, announced the measure as part of a plan to reduce traffic fatalities and serious injuries by 65% by 2035. Currently, four people die in traffic accidents each day, with thousands more sustaining significant injuries annually. While the principle of ensuring driver fitness is widely supported, critics argue the focus on a specific age group is discriminatory and lacks sufficient justification.
Silver Voices Threatens Legal Action
The pressure group Silver Voices, representing 11,000 members, is at the forefront of the opposition. In an official response to a government consultation, the organization urged the Department of Transport to seek guidance from the Equalities and Human Rights Commission before implementing the policy, warning of potential court action.
“This is another example of a policy being announced without the necessary back-up research being done,” stated a spokesperson for Silver Voices. “Picking out the age of 70 for stricter testing without any substantive evidence is likely to contravene age discrimination legislation.”
The group contends the policy is “fundamentally discriminatory,” citing protections under the Equalities Act. They further argue that restricting driving privileges could severely impact older individuals’ access to essential services. “Hundreds of thousands of careful older drivers face being driven off the road because the implementation process has not been thought through,” a senior official explained. “This could be due to difficulties securing a test appointment, affordability concerns, or unreasonably high testing standards not applied to other drivers.”
Concerns Extend Beyond Vision Tests
The government is also considering implementing cognitive testing for older drivers, adding another layer of concern for advocacy groups. Silver Voices has called for a comprehensive impact study to assess the potential consequences of the policy on older people’s lives, including their ability to attend medical appointments and complete essential shopping.
Silver Voices clarified they do not oppose the concept of driver testing, but insist any new regulations must apply universally. “Any new road safety rules should apply to drivers of all ages,” a representative emphasized.
The government’s broader Road Safety Strategy also includes a consultation on lowering the drink-drive limit in England and Wales, which has remained unchanged since 1967. However, the focus on older drivers has overshadowed these other initiatives, fueling accusations of unfair targeting.
The debate highlights the complex challenge of balancing road safety with the rights and needs of an aging population. As the government moves forward with its plans, the threat of legal action from Silver Voices looms large, potentially forcing a reevaluation of the policy and its implications.
