Nexstar and Sinclair End Jimmy Kimmel Boycott Amidst Ratings Surge and Shifting Media Landscape
Table of Contents
Despite initial objections, both Nexstar and Sinclair Broadcast Group reversed their decisions to boycott Jimmy Kimmel Live! on Friday, just days after ABC reinstated the comedian following controversy over remarks made about a potential assassination. The move comes as traditional broadcast television continues to grapple with its role in a media environment increasingly dominated by streaming services.
Nexstar and Sinclair had previously preempted the show in protest, citing concerns over comments Kimmel made regarding Charlie Kirk. However, both companies cited a shift in perspective as the reason for the reversal.
“As a local broadcaster, Nexstar remains committed to protecting the First Amendment while producing and airing local and national news that is fact-based and unbiased and, above all, broadcasting content that is in the best interest of the communities we serve,” a Nexstar representative stated. “We stand apart from cable television, monolithic streaming services, and national networks in our commitment—and obligation—to be stewards of the public airwaves.”
Sinclair similarly attributed its decision to “feedback from viewers, advertisers, and community leaders representing a wide range of perspectives.” The company had initially demanded meetings with ABC to discuss the network’s “commitment to professionalism and accountability” before allowing the show back on air. While those discussions are ongoing, ABC and Disney have yet to accept any of the measures proposed by Sinclair, including the establishment of a network-wide independent ombudsman.
Kimmel’s Return Drives Record Ratings
The reversal of the boycott coincides with a significant boost in viewership for Jimmy Kimmel Live!. Kimmel’s first episode back on air achieved the highest ratings for a regularly scheduled episode in over a decade. His opening monologue, which touched on the First Amendment, the Trump administration, and Erica Kirk’s speech at her late husband’s memorial, garnered over 21 million views on YouTube within days—the most for a monologue in the show’s history.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOUR_YOUTUBE_VIDEO_ID This link leads to Kimmel’s record-breaking monologue.
The comeback episode on Tuesday drew 6.3 million TV viewers, approximately four times the show’s average viewership. Despite 66 ABC affiliates choosing not to broadcast the return episode—effectively blacking out the show for nearly a quarter of the national audience—the program still experienced a substantial surge in viewership.
Blackouts Accelerate Shift to Digital Platforms
Media experts suggest the deliberate blackouts may have inadvertently strengthened digital platforms. “Blackouts like this often highlight the strength of digital platforms,” noted a communications professor at the University of Texas. “Instead of limiting reach, blackouts push viewers toward spaces like YouTube where content spreads faster, lingers longer, and attracts new audiences who may not have tuned in live.”
Another professor at the Rutgers School of Communication and Information echoed this sentiment, stating that the blackouts prompted viewers to seek out Jimmy Kimmel Live! on digital cable packages or YouTube. “There’s this idea of public interest, necessity and convenience that over-the-air broadcast media were supposed to fulfill,” she explained. “So if we all move to streaming services for content because of incidents like this one, it trains viewers to seek media this way.”
This trend is already well underway. Nielsen data indicates that streaming services surpassed cable and broadcast television as America’s most-watched form of TV earlier this year. .
The Future of Broadcast Television and the FCC
The situation raises fundamental questions about the role of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in a rapidly evolving media landscape. The FCC licenses individual broadcast stations, but does not regulate networks like ABC, CBS, NBC, or Fox. As viewership continues to migrate to streaming, the continued relevance of the FCC is being debated.
“I think this is an open question,” one analyst commented. “I think we don’t really know what to think about the ultimate usefulness of the FCC.”
The Nexstar and Sinclair reversal, while seemingly a win for Kimmel and ABC, underscores the challenges facing traditional broadcasters as they navigate a world where content is increasingly consumed on demand and outside the confines of scheduled programming.
Fortune Global Forum returns Oct. 26–27, 2025 in Riyadh. CEOs and global leaders will gather for a dynamic, invitation-only event shaping the future of business. Apply for an invitation.
