Pope Francis Criticizes U.S. Catholic Church’s “Strong, Organized, Reactionary Attitude”
In a surprising statement, Pope Francis expressed his disappointment with the “strong, organized, reactionary attitude” opposing him within the U.S. Roman Catholic Church. The Pope criticized the focus on social issues like abortion and sexuality, which he believes overlooks the care for the poor and the environment.
During a meeting at World Youth Day celebrations in Lisbon, Pope Francis lamented the “backwardness” of some American conservatives who refuse to accept the Church’s evolving mission and the need for changes in doctrine over time. He argued that they hold on to a narrow, outdated vision, which replaces faith with ideologies.
The Pope’s comments were made public this week when a transcript of the conversation was published by the Vatican-vetted Jesuit journal La Civiltà Cattolica. These remarks highlight the Pope’s ongoing concern that some American Catholics have become culture warriors instead of pastors, distorting Church doctrine and presenting an incomplete faith to the faithful.
Pope Francis has consistently emphasized that caring for migrants, the poor, and the environment is as holy a pursuit as opposing abortion. He has called on priests to welcome and minister to marginalized groups, including the gay and divorced communities. Additionally, the Pope has urged the world to address climate change as a moral issue. These priorities differ greatly from the focus of many American conservatives.
For almost a decade, Pope Francis has faced criticism from conservative factions within the Church. Some U.S. bishops have publicly warned against the direction of the Vatican and clashed with the Pope on various issues, including liturgy, abortion, and American politics. Cardinal Raymond Burke, considered a leader of Catholic conservatives, even suggested that Francis risked splitting the Church.
In response to concerns about potential changes to Catholic teaching, Bishop Joseph Strickland warned of a challenge to “basic truths” and hinted at an irrevocable break. Conservative bishops have also confronted Catholic politicians, such as President Joe Biden and former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, over their support for abortion rights.
Conservative media outlets have amplified and encouraged clashes between the Vatican and American bishops. Critics question the Pope’s leadership and legitimacy, accusing him of being anti-American and anticapitalist. Independent websites, such as Church Militant and LifeSite News, closely cover Francis’ perceived missteps and criticize what they consider corrupt church institutions.
Despite the opposition, Pope Francis has consistently argued that the church should be open to change and responsive to the challenges of the times. He rejects the notion that Church doctrine is unchanging and emphasizes the importance of morality and social justice.
While he has isolated vocal conservative clergy members, Pope Francis faces significant conservative influence within the American bishops’ conference. However, the Pope remains steadfast in his mission and expressed his confidence in the face of potential schisms within the Church.