The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback competition intensified after Shedeur Sanders’ second preseason game, with Todd Monken delaying a decision on the starting role amid mixed performances from Sanders and Deshaun Watson.
The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback competition took center stage during NFL preseason Week 2, with Shedeur Sanders and Deshaun Watson vying for the starting role. Todd Monken, the Browns‘ head coach, remained undecided after Watson’s struggles in a 2026 preseason game against the Bills, where he posted a 5-for-12, 35-yard stat line with an interception. Sanders, meanwhile, showed promise but faced criticism for his inconsistent play, including an interception in his second exhibition game. Monken acknowledged the need for more evaluation, stating, I'm saying it kinda jokingly, like at some point, we've got to get that guy the reps.
Browns’ QB Battle: Sanders’ Potential, Watson’s Struggles
Sanders’ performance against the Bills highlighted the uncertainty surrounding the quarterback position. Though he completed 9 of 11 passes for 74 yards and a touchdown, his game was marred by an interception and a weather delay that disrupted the contest. The Browns vs. Bills game was paused due to lightning, with the National Weather Service forecasting an 80% chance of precipitation and a flood watch in effect. Despite the challenges, Sanders’ ability to lead a scoring drive—culminating in a touchdown pass—demonstrated his potential. However, his inconsistent performance across eight games in 2025 raised concerns about his consistency, as noted by NFL executives who ranked him last in a 2026 quarterback tiers list.
Watson’s performance further complicated the race. His 5-for-12, 35-yard outing drew boos from fans, though Monken emphasized that postgame comments from Watson would not influence the decision. The Browns’ depth chart lists Watson as the starter, but Sanders’ improved play in the second preseason game has kept the competition alive. Monken’s reluctance to finalize a choice reflects the staff’s cautious approach, as they weigh Sanders’ progress against Watson’s veteran experience.
49ers’ Passing Game and Jets’ Defensive Shift
The 49ers’ passing game faced scrutiny after Brock Purdy’s underwhelming preseason debut, where he completed 4 of 6 passes for 29 yards. While the team’s running game and defense carried them to a 41-17 victory over the Chargers, concerns lingered about Purdy’s readiness. De’Zhaun Stribling, the 49ers’ second-round draft pick, emerged as a bright spot, tallying four catches for 46 yards. Stribling’s performance, though promising, underscored the 49ers’ reliance on a fragmented receiving corps.
The Jets’ defense, meanwhile, showed signs of improvement. This development contrasted with the Jets’ struggles in the previous campaign, offering cautious optimism for the upcoming regular season. However, the team’s offensive challenges, particularly at quarterback, remained a concern.
What Comes Next for the Browns and Beyond
The Browns’ quarterback decision remains pending, with Monken citing the need to review film and consult with his staff. Sanders’ performance, while not flawless, has positioned him as a legitimate contender, though Watson’s experience and the team’s reliance on him as the starter could tip the scales. The weather delay in the Bills game added an unpredictable element, but Sanders’ ability to adapt under pressure may influence the final call.
For the 49ers, the focus shifts to addressing injuries and refining Purdy’s game. The team’s offensive struggles, exacerbated by the absence of key players, will require strategic adjustments. Meanwhile, the Jets’ defensive improvements offer hope, but their quarterback situation remains a critical factor in their 2026 prospects. As the preseason nears its conclusion, the decisions made by teams like the Browns will shape the narrative heading into the regular season.
