Starlink: the plan by Brazil and China that could “break” the dominance of Elon Musk’s company

by time news

Starlink belongs to billionaire Elon Musk. The plan involves the start of operations of the Chinese satellite company SpaceSail in Brazil, which intends‌ to operate⁢ in the Brazilian market currently ‌led by Starklink. The information was ⁣confirmed to BBC News Brasil by the telecommunications secretary of the Ministry of Communications,‍ Hermano ⁢Barros Tercius.

The idea,⁣ according to Tercius, is for Brazil and China to sign ​memoranda of understanding on the ‌topic during ​Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit to the country on November 20.

However, there is ‌still no‌ deadline for the company to start operating in the country. When contacted, the Chinese⁢ embassy did not⁤ respond to questions sent by the ⁢report.

SpaceSail is a private Chinese company headquartered in ⁣Shanghai ⁤and operates in the broadband Internet market delivered by ⁤low-orbit satellites.

The company currently has‍ 18 satellites, but⁤ its plans call for launching up‌ to 15,000 by ⁤2030. For ‍comparison, Starlink is ‍estimated to have 6,000.

Known as LEO (Low Earth ⁢Orbit), these satellites are smaller and form⁣ real “constellations”⁤ around the Earth. They are located at a distance of about 549 km from the Earth’s surface, while conventional ones would be almost 1,000 km away.

Because they are closer, the data transmission time is⁣ shorter, which allows for a faster⁤ and more reliable Internet connection.

In Brazil, Elon Musk’s Starlink is ⁤the​ leader and holds 45.9% of the satellite Internet market, according to data‌ from the‌ National Telecommunications Agency (Anatel).

But worsening tensions between Musk and Brazilian authorities⁣ have raised rumors about ⁣the possible⁤ effects of the ​country’s dependence on the billionaire’s company.

Photo caption, In Brazil, Musk’s Starlink is already⁤ a leader⁢ in the satellite Internet​ market

Contacts between SpaceSail and Brazil officially began ⁤in‍ mid-August. On the 20th of the same month, a delegation led by the company’s president, Jie Zheng, met with​ representatives of ​the Brazilian government, including

The ‍company’s plans, presented at the⁤ time,‍ envisage entering operations in Brazil⁢ by 2025.

To do⁤ this, however,⁤ the company needs authorizations from Anatel so that, ‍among other things,​ the company can build the ground infrastructure that allows access to the signal from⁤ its satellites in Brazil.

SpaceSail would work similarly to Starlink and other ⁢satellite Internet services. The user should install a small antenna to be ⁢able to access the Internet.

According ‌to Hermano Tercius, one of ⁢the memorandums of understanding negotiated between Brazil and China‌ provides for the technical collaboration necessary for services such as ​SpaceSail to begin operating in the country.

“We are evolving in the texts and discussions to see if we can sign [o memorando]. This would create a more concrete ‌intention to collaborate, which is not yet a commitment. [O memorando] It is the intention to collaborate with what they may be missing [SpaceSail] move up [a entrada em operação]”Tercius tells BBC News Brasil.

The secretary also specified that it is not clear whether the memorandum will involve⁢ only the communications ministries of the ‌two countries or whether ‌SpaceSail and Telebras, a Brazilian state company in the telecommunications ‌sector, will also‍ participate in the document.

One⁢ possibility is that Telebras, which already has contracts with the federal government, could use​ SpaceSail’s services to provide broadband Internet to⁤ schools or other facilities of interest to the Brazilian government.

Tercius said he did not⁤ know whether ‍the crisis involving Elon Musk and ⁤the Federal Supreme Court (STF)‌ had affected negotiations between ‍the two governments.⁢ According to him, the search for new satellite internet service‍ providers is an attempt by Brazil to avoid the formation of “monopolies” in ⁤the sector.

“We try, of course, ⁣to ⁣avoid monopolies⁤ and to have ​this competition so that we know who provides the best service and who offers a⁢ better cost so that the population has⁢ greater⁣ accessibility to this type of service […] Regardless of how the Starlink situation evolves, we hope there will be more suppliers,” says the secretary.

The secretary also specified that the Brazilian government has brought to China the proposal that part of the launches of the satellites of the SpaceSail constellation take place from the Alcântara Launch Center (CLA), in Maranh

“What we tried was to see with them the possibility that, in addition to providing services to Brazil,⁣ they could use our missile launch base to launch satellites⁤ from ⁣here ⁢ […] it will be good ⁢for them because it will‍ be able to accelerate their operational program, and ​it is also good for ‌us because we will make better use of the Alcântara base,” says Tercius.

According to him, another memorandum of understanding being negotiated with China concerns the construction of a​ geostationary satellite to serve Brazil.

According to the secretary, it has ​not yet been defined whether this new satellite will respond only⁤ to communication needs or whether it can also be used⁢ in Brazilian defense‍ systems.

Tension and dominance

Woman standing⁣ on the​ balcony, surrounded by forest, in front of a plastic table with equipment and cables

Photo caption, An ‌employee sets up a Starlink⁤ router⁣ to provide Internet to a chocolate shop on Ilha ⁢do Combu,‍ Belém

The culmination of the crisis between Musk and the Brazilian authorities occurred ⁣on August 30, when the STF decided to suspend the operations of X (formerly Twitter, purchased by Musk in 2022).

Musk reacted to the STF’s⁣ decisions and

The⁣ crisis, however, has spread to ‌another of⁤ Musk’s businesses: the Starlink low-orbit satellite network. The STF even ordered ​the freezing of the company’s accounts in Brazil⁢ after X failed to pay the fines imposed ⁣by the Court.

However, the ‍escalation ‍of the crisis against⁤ Starlink has ​given rise to rumors that the company may suspend its activities in Brazil, similar to what happened with X. And this has left ⁢sectors of the economy and even the military worried.

Starlink is a branch of ​SpaceX, ⁤Elon Musk’s space exploration company.

The company​ provides Internet services through a​ huge network of ⁢satellites. In Brazil, it is often used by people and institutions living⁢ in remote areas, where local ⁢infrastructure such ​as cables and poles does not exist,‌ as is the case in ⁤much of the Amazon.

Experts on the matter say that ⁣the⁢ company currently has the largest constellation of operating satellites in the world and is capable of serving at least 37 countries.

In Brazil, the company’s rise on the market has been meteoric.

In January 2023, Starlink was the fifth largest provider in the ⁤market and responsible for 4.7% of the satellite internet market, according to Anatel.

A year and a half later, in July this ⁣year, the company had already taken the lead ​with a market share of 45.9%.

Currently, in addition to providing broadband Internet to‌ individuals ​in isolated areas, it also provides connection to⁣ Navy ships, Army⁣ military installations, and Petrobras platforms and vessels.

Although ⁣Hermano Tercius says he does not know whether the crisis between Musk and⁤ the Brazilian authorities influenced the government’s decision to look ⁢for new satellite Internet service providers, in the government⁢ of President Luiz⁣ Inácio Lula da Silva (PT), the billionaire‍ is not seen with a good eye.

During the ‍2022 presidential election, Musk declared ⁢support for then-President Jair Bolsonaro (PL).​ In the midst of the crisis with the ST

In August, ​Lula said that Musk had to respect Brazilian laws and that Brazil‍ could not have a “bastard complex.”

“You must respect the decision of the Brazilian‍ Supreme Court. If you ‌want, if you don’t want, be patient. If this were not the case, this country will never be sovereign, this country is not ​a country that has‌ a society with a bastard‍ complex. Because the American screamed and we got scared. NO! This boy must accept the rules of ⁣this country,” Lula said⁢ in an interview with Rádio MaisPB, in Paraíba.

For the technology director of the company Sage Networks, Thiago Ayub, Starlink’s leadership is due to the quality of the service ⁢offered compared to its current competitors.

“This dominance of Starlink is revealed ‍by the indicators we ⁤have observed this year, such as 90% of Amazon cities containing customers of the service⁣ or the concern expressed by the ⁢Brazilian Armed Forces regarding a possible suspension⁢ of the ⁢service due to friction between the company and the STF,”⁣ explains Ayub.

According to him, ⁣however, the increase in the number of satellite Internet service providers could be positive for ⁤the country.

“Having‍ multiple suppliers of ​the same product is an indicator of the health of any market, but⁢ in this particular market, ​since⁣ it ⁣is⁣ strategic, it is ​essential that Brazil manages to attract other Starlink competitors‍ in⁢ the LEO‍ category to serve both the public sector⁤ and private,” ‌he says.

From the Chinese point of view, the acquisition of new markets for this ‌sector is one of the government’s priorities. In 2020, China’s National Development and Reform Commission, one of ‍the country’s ‍top executive bodies, listed ⁣the creation of a new satellite internet infrastructure as one of the country’s major short- and medium-term ⁤goals.

Ue ‍to its​ innovative approach to providing internet access in hard-to-reach areas. ‍Ayub emphasized that the rapid‍ expansion of ⁢Starlink ‍in Brazil aligns with ‌the growing demand for reliable internet, particularly in remote regions of the Amazon, where traditional infrastructure is lacking.

The‌ ongoing tensions between the Brazilian government and Elon Musk have⁤ raised concerns about the future⁣ of Starlink’s operations in the country. As Musk’s other ventures face scrutiny and regulatory ‍challenges, the potential for Starlink to withdraw or⁣ reduce its services ​could significantly impact both civilian users and ⁣critical institutions, including the military and emergency services.

Additionally,​ the Brazilian government is exploring alternative satellite ⁤internet⁢ providers as a response‌ to the escalating situation. This proactive‌ measure ​aims to ensure continued access to ⁣internet services for underserved communities and strategic sectors, ⁣reflecting a broader push for‌ technological autonomy and resilience in⁤ the⁣ face of external pressures.

The timeline of events, particularly Musk’s controversial statements and actions that have drawn ire​ from Brazilian officials, adds complexity to ‍the‌ relationship. With increased scrutiny of Musk’s business practices ⁤and a ⁣more assertive stance from Brasília, the future of satellite internet in‍ Brazil remains ⁣uncertain.

the intertwined narratives of technological advancement,⁣ regulatory action, and geopolitical considerations present a multifaceted landscape that will require careful navigation as Brazil​ seeks to balance its ⁢interests⁣ with global tech giants. The outcome of this situation could reshape the dynamics of internet access not just in ​Brazil, but‌ potentially influence broader trends in satellite communications ⁤worldwide.

You may also like

Leave a Comment