New ‘Superman’ Clip Draws Criticism for Modernizing the Man of Steel
A recently released clip from the upcoming Superman (2025) film has sparked debate among fans, with some expressing concern that the movie is straying too far from the character’s established roots. The scene, an extended cut of an interview between Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) and Clark Kent/Superman (David Corenswet), depicts a pointed interrogation of the hero that has left some viewers questioning the direction of James Gunn‘s take on the iconic character.
The clip, which showcases Lois attempting to understand Superman’s perspective on global affairs, was dissected on a recent live stream hosted by geeks + Gamers (G+G). initial criticism arose when Superman responded to a question about social media with the statement,”Superman has no time for selfies.”
According to one G+G host, Jeremy Griggs, the reference to social media within the “first seven seconds” signaled a concerning trend toward making a timeless character feel overly “current-day.” The discussion continued, focusing on a subsequent exchange between Lois and Clark regarding off-the-record conversations and their use of third-person pronouns.Griggs argued that this dynamic felt out of character, stating, “This isn’t Superman” and contrasting it unfavorably with the portrayals by Christopher Reeve and margot Kidder, who he felt wouldn’t have engaged in such “unstable bulls-t.” He added that the footage “does the movie no favors.”
Griggs confessed to a growing sense of unease about the film, despite his initial desire to enjoy it. His co-host,Steph Anie,known as My Nerdy Home,echoed these concerns,expressing disappointment with the lack of romantic chemistry between Lois and Clark in the scene. She emphasized that a strong sense of love is a basic element of most Superman narratives, and felt the clip portrayed Clark as unable to be authentic around Lois.
Another analyst on the stream differentiated Corenswet’s portrayal from Reeve’s, noting that while Reeve’s Clark Kent was awkward, his Superman maintained a stoic composure that would have prevented him from being “triggered” by Lois’s line of questioning.
“Everything I’ve seen from this movie makes me less and less excited,” griggs stated, directly criticizing Warner Bros./DC Studios for releasing a clip he believes is counterproductive to building anticipation for the film. despite these reservations, Griggs acknowledged positive tracking data and expressed hope that Superman will succeed in theaters, restoring the Man of Steel to his former status as a benchmark for superhero cinema.
Though, another participant, known as Beardo, remained pessimistic, predicting that Gunn’s film would be “garbage.”
The film also stars Edi Cathegi as Mister Terrific. Superman is scheduled for release in July 2025.
NEXT: ‘Superman & Lois’ Star Tyler Hoechlin Stays Humble About Passing The Torch To David Corenswet
The recent reactions to the new Superman (2025) clip highlight a fundamental tension: the desire to honor the character’s legacy while adapting him for a modern audience. As mentioned previously, criticisms center around the perceived modernization of superman, with specific concerns about dialog and character interactions that feel out of sync with established portrayals, like Christopher Reeve’s. However,the question remains: how do you successfully translate a character as iconic as Superman for contemporary audiences? This is the core challenge James Gunn and his team face.
the very essence of Superman lies in his timeless values: truth, justice, and the American way. these principles, though aspirational, have faced various interpretations across the character’s history. The “American way,” in particular,has been subject to re-evaluation as societal understanding and perspectives on justice have evolved. Adaptation, therefore, becomes crucial to ensuring Superman remains relevant.
One key aspect of this adaptation is reflecting the changing ways of the world,which extends to communications. While the “no time for selfies” line has drawn criticism, its also a reflection of how contemporary heroes might navigate social media or other modern technology. The key is to ensure the inclusion does not detract from his core principles and heroic actions. It makes sense that some adaptation is crucial for Superman’s continued relevance.
Exploring the Character Through the Decades
The various interpretations of Superman throughout his eighty-plus years offer insights into this evolution:
- The Golden Age (1938-1950s): Superman emerged as a champion of the common man. He fought corruption, protected the downtrodden, and embodied a straightforward moral compass. This era provided a straightforward, essential version of the character and his role.
- The Silver Age (1950s-1970s): This period embraced more science fiction elements, creating complex storylines featuring clones, alternate realities, and expanded supporting casts. Superman’s powers and adventures became increasingly fantastical.
- The Modern Age (1980s-Present): A darker, more complex Superman began to emerge. Writers delved deeper into his internal conflicts, his responsibilities, and the psychological impact of his abilities. This era brought the stories to a richer level.
Each of these eras reflects the social climate of its time. The Golden Age Superman fought against economic injustice during the Grate Depression. The Silver Age Superman embraced the optimism of the space race. Today’s interpretations grapple with topics like global politics,social responsibility and the balance between personal identity and public duty.
Lessons For Modern Adaptations
Accomplished contemporary adaptations of Superman should keep in mind:
- Core Values: The key is to retain the core values of superman: hope, compassion, and a dedication to doing the right thing. These values will remain timeless.
- Relatability: It is vital for the audience to perceive some of themselves in a way that is relatable. Superman can no longer be a simple, unquestionable savior. He needs to struggle, make difficult choices, and grapple with the complexities of the modern world.
- Integrity: Any changes within Superman must serve the story and the character’s fundamental ideals. If so, the changes will work, and if not, they will not.
The new Superman (2025) film will need to balance tradition with the demands of the modern era. this involves examining the character’s past and adapting it to a changing world. By staying true to the core of the character while providing a narrative that connects with today’s viewers, the film would have a high probability of success.
Is the 2025 Film ‘On Track’?
The initial reactions to the recent trailer raise questions about whether the film strikes the right balance. The dialogue, the interactions between the characters, and the tone of the scenes will all play a part in its success. The creators will need to show that they share a vision that honors the character’s roots while offering a fresh take that resonates with present-day audiences.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can the film balance honoring Superman’s legacy with modernizing him?
the film needs to respect established character traits and narratives while incorporating elements that mirror the current world. This might include updated settings,thematic explorations,and relatable dialogue that emphasizes his moral core.
What role does Lois Lane play in the success of a Superman adaptation?
Lois Lane is not only a romantic partner but also a key element in how to reveal the human side of Superman. their relationship and interactions with her often highlight the character’s compassion and internal struggles.
Will the film’s “Man of Steel” maintain relevancy in today’s environment?
Superman has the potential to always remain relevant because the core values he embodies-hope, truth, and justice-are timeless concepts.However, the specific ways those values are presented needs to change as society does, which is why the adaptations must be executed carefully.
Table of Contents
