The College Football Playoff Committee Faces Its Most Difficult Decision Yet
After Alabama’s stunning 27-24 victory over Georgia in the SEC Championship Game, the College Football Playoff Committee is faced with a high-profile decision. With Alabama, Georgia, and Texas all tied at 12-1, the battle for the final playoff spot has intensified.
The other three College Football Playoff spots could be filled by Michigan, Florida State, and Washington, all of whom have solid cases for inclusion. Now, the three powerhouses – Alabama, Georgia, and Texas – are vying for the last spot in the coveted College Football Playoff.
However, the decision should not be as difficult as it may seem. According to the College Football Playoff’s own criteria, Texas should be included, while Alabama and Georgia should be left out.
Firstly, the committee considers championship wins. Both Alabama and Texas have secured a championship, while Georgia has not. In terms of strength of schedule, Texas ranks higher than both Alabama and Georgia, sitting at No. 11 in FPI strength of schedule.
Considering head-to-head competition, Texas holds a 1-0 record against both Alabama and Georgia. The Longhorns’ victory against Alabama was decisive, and their stronger case is furthered by better strength of schedule.
To make the case even clearer, Texas did not have any common opponents with Alabama or Georgia, other than Alabama itself – resulting in a win for Texas and a loss for Georgia.
With these criteria in mind, Georgia’s case for inclusion is weakened. The consideration then shifts to Alabama versus Texas. Despite an argument that Alabama has grown since their loss against Texas, the committee has made it clear that head-to-head competition is a decisive factor.
Amid the debate, Steve Sarkisian has led the Longhorns back to national relevance, with three wins over ranked opponents and a strong defense. Texas has demonstrated the capability to contest for the national title.
Considering the unprecedented situation where all five power conference champions have finished 12-1 or better, it is clear that Texas belongs in the field. The decision to leave out Alabama and Georgia in favor of Texas is backed by the committee’s own criteria and offers a clear path to a more inclusive and competitive College Football Playoff field.