Tony Butala, the last surviving original member and co-founder of the Grammy-nominated vocal trio The Lettermen, died on November 1 at the age of 87 in Manitowoc, Wisconsin, according to USA Today. Group manager David Haskell stated that the singer passed away after battling health issues in recent years.
The vocal group, known for smooth three-part harmonies and romantic ballads, earned four Grammy nominations, 11 gold records, and 32 consecutive charting albums on Billboard over a career spanning more than six decades. Butala co-founded the ensemble in the late 1950s alongside Jim Pike, who died in 2018 at age 92, and Bob Engemann, who died in 2013 at age 77.
Tony Butala, founding member of '60s pop group The Lettermen, dies at 87 https://t.co/PPAftvLm4n
Childhood Stardom in Pennsylvania and Early Hollywood Film Roles
Born in 1938 in Sharon, Pennsylvania, he began singing professionally at age 7 before performing on KDKA Radio in Pittsburgh at age 8, as reported by the Sharon Herald.
By age 10, he relocated with his mother to Los Angeles, joining the Mitchell Boys Choir, with whom he performed through 1954. During his tenure, the choir director kept him on as assistant choir director and paid for his private schooling when his voice changed. He secured several film roles, including appearances in White Christmas, On Moonlight Bay, and Disney’s animated classic Peter Pan (where he provided the singing voice for the Lost Boy known as Fox, or Slightly), alongside work in War of the Worlds, according to That Eric Alper.
Signing with Capitol Records and Charting Hits
As a teenager, he sang in a quartet called The Fourmost alongside a young Concetta Ingolia, who would become actress and singer Connie Stevens. After trying out early versions of the group with Mike Barnett and Talmadge Russell, Butala teamed up with Jim Pike and Bob Engemann to form The Lettermen in the late 1950s. The trio signed with Capitol Records in 1961, releasing a version of The Way You Look Tonight—a standard originally performed by Fred Astaire that climbed to Number 13 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart, as detailed by Billboard.
Other classics followed, including Hurt So Bad (1969), and their last hit in 1971, Everything is Good About You. The beloved group toured constantly, playing colleges across the country and venues around the world. In April 2009, Butala and The Lettermen recorded an album in Newton Falls.
Stepping Away from Performing and Receiving Honors
Butala stepped away from performing in 2019, though he made a surprise appearance in June 2025 to join the group in song during a performance in Manitowoc, Wisconsin, according to USA Today. In 2020, Butala and the group received a star on the Hollywood Walk, which was nominated and sponsored by The Lettermen Friends Fan Club. Following his death, condolences were directed to the family care of The Lettermen Community Project at P.O. Box 312 in Cortland.
He lived to bring people joy. He never met a person he didn’t like. It could’ve been the janitor and he’s going to strike up a conversation because he felt that people needed that.
USA TODAY
In accordance with Butala’s wishes, there will be no public viewing. The band’s official statement shared the lyrics of his final public solo performance, the classic song Smile written by Charlie Chaplin: Smile though your heart is aching / Smile even though it's breaking / When there are clouds in the sky you'll get by / If you smile through your fear and sorrow / Smile and maybe tomorrow / You'll see the sun come shining through / For you.
Celebrations of life are scheduled to take place in Wisconsin and California, with the family requesting that memorial donations be directed to the Lakeshore Humane Society in Manitowoc.
More on Tony Butala
Tony Butala, co-founder of The Lettermen group known for 'The Way You Look Tonight,' dies at 87 | LINK IN BIO pic.twitter.com/86CXPe8NXX
Tony Butala, co-founder of The Lettermen known for ‘When I Fall in Love,’ dies at 87 https://t.co/VRmkUFSLgO
The Lettermen’s Tony Butala Dies at 87https://t.co/baW4VC53hH