Ancient Caribbean coral reefs dating back to 125,000 to 130,000 years ago help researchers plan modern marine conservation.
Coral reefs across the Caribbean have declined sharply over the past 70 years, leaving modern researchers with a limited baseline for what a healthy ecosystem looks like. A research team turned to fossilized reef remnants sitting meters away from living corals in northeastern Jamaica.
Researchers examined Late Pleistocene fossil reefs at two locations in Jamaica. “Because we were studying already damaged reefs (in the modern-day Caribbean), we had a limited baseline of what a healthy reef used to look like and were missing understandings of things like resilience,” said Claire Williams, who led research on the fossil and modern reefs while earning a doctorate at the UT Jackson School of Geosciences.
“So, my theory was that by bringing in the fossil record, we could get a richer picture of coral tolerances and make better predictions for the future,” Williams said.
Investigators walked along the ancient fossil reefs to take photographs and estimate local coral numbers and distributions.
Investigators observed that branching coral varieties known as Acropora—specifically Acropora palmata and Acropora cervicornis—that thrived during the Pleistocene period are mostly dead and overgrown with algae.
Remaining live corals are predominantly Porites astreoides, a globular species that recovers quickly from disturbances but fails to provide essential structural habitat. “These big branching species provide a lot of habitat and offshore protection. With that gone, we’ve lost that function on the reef,” Williams said.
Conservation groups use coral gardening to nurture and transplant new corals from nurseries to damaged areas. Rising ocean temperatures complicate these efforts.
“We can nurture and transplant new, healthy corals from nurseries to damaged reefs, often referred to as coral gardening, but if they are in a place that’s too hot in the future, they’re not going to survive,” said Rowan Martindale, an associate professor at the Jackson School’s Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences.
Martindale collaborated on the studies alongside Fernando Machado-Stredel and Corinne E. Myers from The University of New Mexico.
The team combined modern occurrences with mid-Holocene records from 5,000 to 7,000 years ago and Pleistocene data into ecological niche models. Integrating mid-Holocene fossil data generated up to 114,559 square kilometers more predicted habitat by 2100 than models based on modern data.
The models indicate that the northern Caribbean, the Florida Keys, and the Yucatan Peninsula possess optimal temperature and salinity profiles for future reef-building species under climate scenarios stretching toward 2050 and 2100.
“The fossil record can improve our predictions and provide best-case ideas of where things might be able to survive,” Williams said. “Conservation needs to be adaptive and to keep learning new information.”
Coral reefs across the Caribbean have declined sharply over the past 70 years.