MLB Executives Predict 2026 Rookie of the year Standouts: yesavage and McGonigle Lead the Pack
Table of Contents
Baseball front offices are already looking ahead to 2026, and a recent MLB Pipeline survey reveals a fascinating, albeit fragmented, outlook on who will emerge as the top rookies in each league. More then 40 officials – from general managers to scouting directors – weighed in,demonstrating a lack of consensus but highlighting a wealth of promising young talent.
American League Rookie of the Year Race: Pitching and Hitting Tie at the Top
The American League race appears particularly tight, with Trey Yesavage and Kevin McGonigle emerging as co-leaders in the predictions. This mirrors a similar dynamic in the National League, where a pitcher and a hitter also share the top spot. Interestingly, the AL leaders represent contrasting profiles: a pitcher who excelled in the postseason and a hitter yet to play above Double-A.
Yesavage, the No. 3 overall prospect, made a splash with the Yankees in September, posting a 2.50 ERA and 35 strikeouts in 30.1 innings. His dominant stuff and composure under pressure undoubtedly swayed many voters. He is widely considered the best pure hitter in the minors, possessing an advanced approach that suggests he can compete at the highest level. His potential position in the Tigers’ infield – primarily shortstop, but also capable at second and third base – will be a key storyline this spring.
Several other players garnered attention, including Samuel Basallo (MLB No. 7), who debuted with the Orioles in August 2025, and Carter Jensen (MLB No. 39), a September call-up for the royals who posted a .941 OPS in 60 at-bats. Red Sox lefties Payton Tolle (MLB No. 28) and Connelly Early (BOS No. 4) also received votes, as did prospects from the Tigers (Max Clark), Guardians (Chase delauter, Travis Bazzana), and Athletics (Jamie Arnold, Leo De Vries). The Athletics, notably, finished 1-2 in the 2025 AL ROY voting.
National League Rookie of the Year: A Similar Story of Rising Stars
The National League predictions echo the AL’s trend, featuring a top tier led by a hitter with limited big league experience and a pitcher who made a strong debut. JJ Wetherholt (MLB No. 5),a Cardinals infielder,impressed in his first full professional season,splitting time between double-A and triple-A and posting a .306/.421/.510 slash line with 17 home runs and 23 stolen bases. Despite not receiving a late-season call-up to St. Louis, many anticipate he will quickly earn a spot in the lineup.
Alongside Wetherholt, Nolan McLean (MLB no. 11) stands out. He made a significant impact with the Mets during their playoff push, delivering eight outstanding starts with a 2.06 ERA and 10.7 K/9 rate. McLean is the only player to receive actual ROY votes in 2025 among all surveyed for 2026.
rounding out the top contenders is Konnor Griffin, the No. 1 prospect, who rapidly ascended from Single-A to Double-A in 2025, hitting .333/.415/.527 with 21 home runs and 65 steals,earning him MLB Pipeline’s Hitting Prospect of the Year award.
Other players receiving votes include Bubba Chandler (MLB No. 14) and Sal Stewart (MLB No. 31), both of whom have already seen big league action, as well as Justin Crawford (MLB No. 54) and Zyhir Hope (MLB No. 20). The Pirates, with Chandler and Griffin, are the only team with two players among the leaders, while the Phillies and Mets also boast multiple prospects in the running.
The survey underscores the difficulty in predicting future success, but it provides a valuable snapshot of the talent poised to make an impact in Major League Baseball in the coming years.Whether these predictions will hold true remains to be seen, but the excitement surrounding these young players is palpable as the 2026 season approaches.
Worth a look
