Desmond Bane Trade Grades: Magic & Grizzlies’ First Big Deal

by liam.oconnor - Sports Editor

ORLANDO, june 15, 2025

The NBA trade season has kicked off wiht a bang, as the orlando Magic and Memphis Grizzlies agreed to a critically important deal, shaking up the league’s landscape. This blockbuster trade aims to elevate the Magic to the upper echelon of the Eastern Conference.

The Orlando Magic are making a bold move, acquiring Desmond Bane in a trade that could reshape the Eastern Conference, while the Grizzlies begin a strategic rebuild.

  • Orlando acquired Desmond Bane from Memphis.
  • Memphis received kentavious Caldwell-Pope, Cole Anthony, four first-round picks, and a pick swap.
  • the Magic are addressing their shooting woes.
  • The Grizzlies are taking a step back, focusing on the future.

What exactly did the Orlando Magic give up to land Desmond Bane? The Magic traded for Bane, acquiring the sharpshooter from the Memphis Grizzlies in exchange for Kentavious Caldwell-Pope, Cole Anthony, four first-round picks, and a pick swap. According to ESPN insider Shams Charania, Memphis also gets the No. 16 pick in the 2025 NBA Draft, the Suns’ first-round pick in 2026, and the Magic’s unprotected 2028 and 2030 first-round picks, along with a “lightly protected” first-round swap in 2029.

Reader question:-How will the pick swap effect each team’s long-term strategy, especially if one team significantly outperforms the other in 2029? Share your thoughts below.

Bane’s Impact and Fit

Desmond Bane, tho not yet an All-Star, has consistently played at that level for the past four seasons. He’s recognized as one of the league’s premier three-point shooters, boasting a career average of 41% from beyond the arc on 6.4 attempts per game. Additionally, bane is a tenacious defender who can effectively guard lead ball-handlers and smaller wings. He will turn 27 before the next season starts.

the Magic are making an all-in push to address their most pressing need, while the Grizzlies are taking a surprising step back. Let’s break down the trade grades for each team.

Magic Trade Grade

the orlando Magic struggled mightily with their shooting during the season, ranking at the bottom of the league by converting only 31.8% of their team three-pointers. This lack of shooting and spacing hindered orlando’s offense, resulting in a 108.9 offensive rating, placing them at No. 27 in the NBA. the team’s offensive struggles were even more pronounced during their first-round playoff series against the Boston Celtics, were they achieved a 103.8 offensive rating.

Did you know?-The Orlando magic’s three-point percentage of 31.8% was the worst in the NBA last season. This glaring weakness was a major factor in their offensive struggles and ultimately prompted the acquisition of Desmond Bane.

Despite the offensive challenges,Orlando achieved a 41-41 record and secured the No. 7 seed in the East, thanks to their elite defense.The challenge for the Magic this offseason was to improve their shooting without compromising their No. 2 ranked defense in the league. The trade for Bane addresses this perfectly, albeit at a considerable cost.

Bane is the perfect fit for what the Magic need. He is an elite shooter,a solid defender,and a capable secondary creator with the ball in his hands. Orlando needed an extra ball handler, a knockdown shooter, and someone who could keep the machine running on defense, and they found it all in one player.

The Magic faced injury challenges last season, with key players like Paolo Banchero, Franz Wagner, and Jalen Suggs missing significant time. Wagner performed at an All-NBA level when leading lineups without Banchero. Banchero had impressive performances early in the season but struggled with scoring efficiency. suggs, before a knee injury ended his season after 35 games, was having his best year, averaging 16.2 points per game with consistently excellent defense.

The Magic believe Wagner and Banchero can develop into All-NBA caliber players. Suggs is one of the best defensive guards in the league and is showing signs of offensive growth. Bane’s arrival brings the necessary shooting to this unit, while providing another guard to handle pressure and run secondary actions.

The fit between Bane and the Magic is ideal. However, the cost was high.

The Phoenix’s 2026 first-round pick is incredibly valuable, and trading unprotected first-rounders in 2028 and 2030 is risky if this core doesn’t succeed. Bane is a great player and a perfect fit, but he hasn’t been an All-Star. This feels like a steep price. The Magic also face increasing financial commitments. Wagner and Banchero will be on max deals after the 2025-26 season.Suggs is on a $30 million per year deal, and Bane’s contract ranges from $36 million to $45 million annually until it expires in 2029. The Magic’s depth might be threatened with this type of payroll, but they could have a strong bench next season.

The Eastern Conference is anticipated to be less competitive next season due to injuries to key players such as jayson Tatum and Damian Lillard. The Magic made this trade because they see an opportunity in the East and believe they can win it all after adding Bane to their core. It’s an incredibly bold move,but the roster is now talented enough to challenge the Cavs,Knicks,and Pacers at the top of the East,and there’s a real chance they could break through.

Magic grade: B+

Grizzlies Trade Grade

The Grizzlies held the No. 2 seed in the Western Conference for a considerable part of the season. Their performance declined after the All-Star break, and they fired their head coach in a surprising move, eventually getting swept in the first round of the playoffs by the Oklahoma City Thunder.

Memphis clearly reached a breaking point when it fired Taylor Jenkins, who has now officially been replaced by former assistant Tuomas Iisalo. The Grizzlies weren’t that far off in the West despite their rough finish, with 48 wins earning them the No. 8 seed. If the Thunder are the standard for contention, Memphis was clearly not close, which is why they’re trading one of their best players.

This is a substantial haul for Memphis to help reset their roster. The Grizzlies are one of the most analytically-driven teams in the league, acquiring three picks with high potential, along with a solid No. 16 overall pick this year. The Suns may be about to trade Kevin Durant and could take a step back next season, making their 2026 pick very appealing.Caldwell-Pope and Anthony should contribute as well, whether Memphis develops their value to trade them or uses them as depth pieces this season.

Will the Grizzlies trade Ja Morant or Jaren Jackson Jr.? GM Zach Kleinman has stated Morant isn’t on the market. I believe Memphis should still be good next season with caldwell-Pope and Anthony replacing Bane, and the picks make their future so much more captivating.

Ultimately, the Grizzlies couldn’t break through with this core. They did well to move off of it early instead of holding on too long.

Grizzlies grade: A-

Breaking Down the Bane Trade: Long-Term Implications

The acquisition of Desmond Bane by the Orlando Magic signals their unwavering commitment to contending for an NBA title. This blockbuster trade, while immediately addressing the team’s shooting woes, also raises questions about the franchise’s long-term trajectory. Is this a calculated risk worth taking, or could it backfire, leaving the Magic regretting the cost?

Bane’s arrival presents both immediate benefits and potential future challenges for Orlando. The team now boasts a more balanced roster. Bane’s ability to consistently knock down shots from beyond the arc provides much-needed spacing for the Magic’s young core. This spacing makes the offense harder to guard because it opens up driving lanes for Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner, creating new scoring opportunities. His presence also lifts some of the scoring pressure from Jalen Suggs, allowing him to prioritize defense and playmaking.

The cost is clear. The Magic are essentially betting their future on the current core’s ability to win championships. Trading multiple first-round picks is a significant gamble, especially when those picks are unprotected far into the future.The performance of players like Caldwell-Pope and Anthony will also determine if their expiring contracts have any value or become dead weight on Memphis’s roster.

Let’s consider the primary advantages and risks associated with this high-stakes trade.

The Pros of the Bane Trade

  • Enhanced Offense: Bane drastically improves Orlando’s three-point shooting efficiency, making them a more risky team overall.His 41% career average from deep is a significant upgrade.
  • Reduced Burden on key Players: Bane’s secondary creation skills and scoring ability will take some of the pressure off of Banchero and Wagner.
  • Immediate Playoff Contender: If the team stays healthy, the Magic should have a better chance of going deep in the playoffs.

The Cons of the Bane Trade

  • Future Draft Capital Depleted: The Magic surrendered valuable draft picks. Thes picks represent potential future talent.
  • Financial Constraints: With impending max contracts for Banchero and Wagner, the team must carefully manage its finances moving forward. This limits versatility to add quality role players.
  • Injury Risk: As we saw last season, injuries can derail even the best-laid plans. The team needs to stay healthy to make the investment pay off.

What exactly does this trade mean for the Magic’s future flexibility? The trade substantially limits the Magic’s draft capital and financial flexibility. The team will need to rely on shrewd drafting and smart acquisitions. Additionally, they will be under immense pressure for the core to produce immediately.

If the core does not live up to the expectations, the Magic could enter a prolonged rebuilding phase. Managing expectations and staying the course if the team struggles will be critical.

Why did the Magic make this trade? The Magic are signaling they intend to compete for an NBA title. They are betting on their core of young players and have now added shooting and skill to the team.

FAQs

How does Desmond Bane affect the Magic’s offensive strategy?

Bane will likely slot into the starting lineup and provide critical floor spacing. This will open up the floor for driving lanes, and he’ll be a major scoring threat to keep defenses honest.

What is the risk associated with the draft picks given up?

If the core doesn’t succeed, those picks can turn into top selections that the Magic could have acquired to begin a rebuild. Losing future potential talent could hurt the franchise in the long run.

How realistic is it that the Magic break through in the East?

The Magic have a reasonable chance. The East is expected to be less competitive next season if key players on other teams miss time. By improving their shooting, the team is better positioned to compete with other top teams in the East.

You may also like

Leave a Comment