BOSTON, 2025-06-16 10:03:00
Massachusetts Housing Costs Skyrocket, Leaving Many Behind
Home prices have far outpaced incomes in Massachusetts, making it increasingly arduous for residents to afford housing.
- Housing costs in Massachusetts have grown much faster than incomes.
- In Greater Boston in 2023, the house-price-to-income ratio was 6.3.
- Many average earners face a difficult choice: rent forever or leave the state.
The widening gap between home prices and incomes in Massachusetts is creating an affordability crisis, making it difficult for many to buy a home. Albert Saiz, an associate professor of urban economics and real estate at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, stated that the disparity between what peopel earn and what homes cost is “completely outrageous.”
Economists often use the house-price-to-income ratio to gauge the health of a housing market. A ratio of three is generally considered healthy,meaning a median household income of $100,000 with a median home price of $300,000,as an example.
In Greater Boston, though, that ratio was 6.3 in 2023, according to Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies. This is more than double the healthy rate.
What is a healthy house-price-to-income ratio? A ratio of 3 or below is generally considered healthy, indicating a balanced housing market where homes are relatively affordable compared to local incomes.
The last time the price-to-income ratio was this high was in the mid-2000s, just before the housing market crashed, triggering the Great Recession.
The Root of the Problem
The growing gap between incomes and home prices is largely due to the state’s housing shortage, which began to worsen in the 2000s. This shortage is a result of underbuilding over several decades, coupled with rising demand to live in the state and a surge in high-wage jobs.
Keren Horn, an associate professor of economics at UMass Boston, noted that the kind of homes developers build also plays a role in the rise in home prices.
For years, builders constructed smaller, more affordable “starter homes” in the suburbs of Boston. Now, many new single-family homes are larger “McMansions,” often built on the lots of older starter homes that have been torn down. This trend contributes to rising house prices, even though it is indeed partially related to the high cost of land, especially in Greater Boston.
“We’re seeing decades and decades of bad housing policy catching up to us,” Horn said. “Housing is supposed to be affordable to the people who need it. We can’t expect to have a healthy region if the current price trajectory continues.”
Income vs. Home Prices: A Growing Divide
From 1987 through 2022, the median income in Massachusetts rose by about 190 percent, while the price of a typical single-family home increased by nearly 300 percent.
Income vs. Home Price Growth (1987-2022):
- Median Income: +190%
- Typical Home Price: +300%
While housing has always been expensive in Massachusetts compared to national standards, the state, especially Greater Boston, also has higher incomes than most of the country. Despite this, a household now needs to earn roughly $217,000 a year to afford the typical house hear, according to Harvard’s housing center.
This divergence in prices and incomes changes who can own a home in Massachusetts. In the 1980s and before, when incomes and home prices were aligned, homeownership was an accessible tool for wealth-building for working and middle-class families. Many families who bought homes then have seen their values increase substantially, creating assets for younger generations.
Now, that same pathway to generational wealth is much more difficult to access, leaving many average earners with two options: rent indefinitely or leave the state.
“We are going to witness a huge generational divide, in terms of access to wealth,” Saiz said.”Or people are just going to find somewhere else to live.”
The Massachusetts housing market presents a complex challenge, but solutions are possible. Addressing the core issue of supply and demand is crucial to restoring affordability and ensuring that the dream of homeownership remains within reach for a broader segment of the population. The key lies in understanding the factors driving the current crisis and exploring potential remedies.
as previously mentioned, the primary driver of the Massachusetts housing crisis is a severe shortage of available housing, compounded by rising demand and constricted supply. This shortage has created a market where prices are significantly inflated relative to the income levels of many residents [[1]]. The stateS historical underbuilding of housing units has not kept pace with population growth, leading to intense competition for the limited existing homes. This imbalance between supply and demand allows prices to remain high.
To further exacerbate this demand, the increase in high-wage jobs in Massachusetts over recent decades has attracted more people to the state. This influx of new residents puts additional strain on the housing market, worsening the existing supply issues and contributing to price increases.
The type of housing being constructed is also critical. As mentioned earlier, the trend toward building larger, more expensive homes, often replacing smaller, more affordable ones, has contributed to escalating prices [[3]]. While there will always be a market of high earners seeking luxury or larger residences, the scarcity of “starter homes” and moderately priced housing options makes it much tough for many families to enter the market.
Potential Solutions and Policy Initiatives
Several strategies and policy initiatives are being explored to tackle the housing crisis.
Increasing Housing Supply: the focus of many proposals is to increase the overall supply of housing. this includes streamlining zoning regulations to allow for higher-density housing, such as apartments and townhouses, and incentivizing developers to build more affordable units. Some measures being discussed involve reducing permitting times and fees to encourage new construction. Furthermore, the state government can offer subsidies or tax breaks to developers willing to build affordable housing.
Incentivizing Affordable Housing: Policies that specifically target the construction of affordable housing are essential. Local officials can implement inclusionary zoning requirements, which mandate a percentage of affordable units in new developments. The state could also establish funding mechanisms,such as transfer fees on high-value property sales,to generate revenue specifically for affordable housing growth [[2]].
Supporting Renters and Homebuyers: Efforts to support renters and first-time homebuyers can also help ease the crisis. These might include financial assistance programs,such as down payment assistance or rental subsidies,as well as tenant protections to prevent displacement and ensure housing stability. These measures help households access safe and affordable housing in the short and long term.
Promoting Density and Transit-Oriented Development: Encouraging higher-density housing near public transportation hubs can promote affordability while reducing reliance on cars. This strategy supports urban planning goals and integrates housing into existing infrastructure.
The Massachusetts housing crisis can be described by the growing gap between rising home prices and stagnant incomes. The lack of housing creates high prices and a difficult market.
Benefits & Practical Tips: What You Can Do Now
- Educate Yourself: Stay informed about local housing issues and proposed solutions. Understanding the complexities of the market will give you insight into the problem.
- Contact Your Representatives: Advocate for policies that promote affordable housing and address supply constraints. Your voice matters to elected officials.
- Explore Homebuyer Assistance Programs: Investigate state and federal programs that provide help with down payments, closing costs, and mortgages.
- Consider Different Housing Options: Be open to renting, co-housing, or exploring option housing types like accessory dwelling units (ADUs).
- Budget Wisely: Maintain a realistic budget and consult with a financial advisor to plan your housing costs.
FAQs
Q: What is the biggest factor driving the housing crisis in Massachusetts?
A: The most important factor is the imbalance between housing supply and demand, worsened by historical underbuilding and strong demand.
Q: How can I stay informed about housing developments in my area?
A: Attend local community meetings, follow relevant news sources, and stay engaged with local policymakers.
Q: What are transfer fees, and how do they relate to affordable housing?
A: Transfer fees are small charges on real estate transactions over a certain value, and they can be used to fund the development of affordable housing units [[2]].
Q: What can I do if I cannot afford to purchase a home in Massachusetts?
A: Consider renting, explore affordable housing programs, or look for housing options in more affordable communities.
Q: will the housing crisis ever be resolved in Massachusetts?
A: While there is no swift fix, the crisis can be significantly mitigated through policy changes, increased construction, and innovative housing solutions.
Table of Contents
