Arizona Pizza Powerhouses Dominate 50 Top Pizza USA 2025 Rankings
Arizona’s vibrant pizza scene has earned significant recognition with the release of the 50 Top Pizza USA 2025 list, showcasing the state’s rising culinary prowess. Three Arizona pizzerias – Craft 64, Penelope Pizza, and Pomo Pizzeria Napoletano – have been lauded by the prestigious international guide, solidifying the region’s position as a destination for pizza aficionados.
The 50 Top Pizza Guide: A Global Benchmark
Established in 2018, 50 Top Pizza has become a leading authority in evaluating pizzerias worldwide, not simply the quality of the pizza itself, but the complete dining experience. The guide, which expanded to include the U.S. in 2021, employs anonymous judges who assess pizza quality, service, ambiance, and beverage programs. According to a company release, the curators – Barbara Guerra, Luciano Pignataro, and Albert Sapere – aim to represent the pinnacle of the industry, comparing their ranking system to “what the NBA is for basketball.”
Craft 64 Rises in the Ranks
Craft 64, with locations in Scottsdale and Chandler, achieved a notable climb in the rankings, securing the No. 26 spot in 2025, up from No. 32 in 2024. The pizzeria is celebrated for its rustic atmosphere, wood-fired pizzas, and extensive craft beer selection. Judges specifically highlighted the quality of the dough – described as thin yet sturdy – and recommended the “La Smokehouse” pie, featuring mozzarella, parmesan, fennel cream, smoked onions, and roasted mushrooms.
Details: 6922 E. Main St., Scottsdale, 480-946-0542. Also, 68 W. Buffalo St., Chandler, 480-247-3002, craft64.com/home.
Penelope Pizza: Tucson’s Rising Star
Penelope Pizza in Tucson earned the No. 42 position on the 2025 list, improving from its No. 46 ranking in 2024. The pizzeria, which began as a food truck, has impressed inspectors with its Neapolitan-style pizzas and lively atmosphere. The menu features ingredients like Calabrian pesto oil, mortadella, burrata, pistachio, and house-made sausage, alongside lasagna, wine, beer, and cocktails, all served with a focus on speed and hospitality.
Details: 800 N. Kolb Road, Tucson, (520) 633-5571, penelopepizza.com.
Pomo Pizzeria Napoletano: An “Excellent” Choice
Pomo Pizzeria Napoletano, with locations in Scottsdale and Phoenix, was recognized on the “Excellent Pizzeria” list for 2025. While not reaching the Top 50, the judges lauded Pomo’s wood-fired pizza for its “fragrant crust, airy cornicione, and high-quality toppings,” specifically mentioning the Burratella and Margherita pies. The pizzeria previously ranked No. 40 on the Top 50 list in 2024.
Details: 8977 N. Scottsdale Road #504, Scottsdale, 480-998-1366. Also, 2502 E. Camelback Road, STE A and B, Phoenix, 602-954-5221. And, 705 N. First St., Unit 120, Phoenix, 602-795-2555, pomopizzeria.com.
These accolades underscore the growing sophistication and quality of Arizona’s pizza scene, attracting attention from both national and international culinary experts. The success of these pizzerias demonstrates a commitment to quality ingredients, innovative techniques, and a dedication to providing exceptional dining experiences.
