Cecil B. DeMille’s Lost Film Location: A Flagstaff “What If?”
Table of Contents
A fascinating, though likely untrue, story suggests Arizona nearly became the birthplace of feature filmmaking, but Cecil B. DeMille’s dissatisfaction with the state’s climate and scenery led him to establish Hollywood instead. The tale highlights the often-unforeseen factors that shape cultural and economic landscapes.
The legend centers around DeMille’s initial consideration of Flagstaff as the location for his first full-length motion picture. According to the account, the famed director scouted the area but ultimately deemed the weather unsuitable and the terrain incompatible with the aesthetic demands of a Western film. He subsequently chose to continue his journey westward, ultimately settling on Los Angeles and laying the foundation for the entertainment industry as we know it.
The Flagstaff Prospect: A Climate and Landscape Dispute
DeMille’s alleged concerns weren’t about a lack of potential, but rather a mismatch between the environment and his artistic vision. The story suggests he believed Flagstaff’s landscape didn’t adequately evoke the imagery traditionally associated with Westerns. This is a crucial point, as it underscores the importance of location in shaping the narrative and visual identity of early cinema.
It’s important to note, however, that the veracity of this account is questionable. One source describes the story as “probably apocryphal,” meaning its historical accuracy is doubtful. Despite this uncertainty, the narrative serves as a compelling illustration of how seemingly minor decisions can have significant, long-term consequences.
Missed Opportunities and the Rise of Hollywood
Regardless of whether DeMille truly considered Flagstaff, the anecdote prompts reflection on the “what ifs” of history. Had circumstances been different, Arizona might have become a major film production hub, potentially altering the state’s economic and cultural trajectory.
The story also highlights the serendipitous nature of Hollywood’s origins. The choice of Los Angeles wasn’t necessarily based on a master plan, but rather on a combination of factors, including climate, available land, and perhaps, a degree of chance. The missed opportunities, “whatever the case,” serve as a reminder that even the most iconic industries can emerge from unexpected beginnings.
