Agnez Mo Faces Ongoing Legal Battle Over “Bilang Saja” Royalty Dispute
Table of Contents
A protracted copyright and royalty lawsuit involving Indonesian singer Agnez Mo continues to unfold at the Central Jakarta Commercial Court, raising questions about artist rights and intellectual property enforcement in the music industry. The case, centered around the popular song “Bilang Saja,” has seen multiple legal proceedings and a reversal of fortune for both the artist and the original songwriter.
The dispute originated with claims from Ari Bias, the creator of “Bilang Saja,” who alleged unpaid royalties from performances of the song by Agnez Mo. The legal battle has captivated industry observers and sparked debate about fair compensation for songwriters.
Agnez Mo’s Absence From Court Proceedings
Agnez Mo, legally named Agnes Monica, has been absent from three court hearings related to the case. According to a press statement, the singer has been legally summoned on three separate occasions, most recently with a request to attend on January 6 to finalize documentation regarding her legal standing as a defendant. A court official stated that Co-Defendant I and Co-Defendant III will not be required to appear at the next scheduled meeting.
The case, registered under number 136/Pdt.Sus-HKI/Cipta/2025/PN Niaga Jkt.Pst., lists PT Aneka Bintang Gading as the primary defendant, with Agnez Monica (Co-Defendant I), the National Collective Management Institute (Co-Defendant II), and the Karya Cipta Indonesia Collective Management Institute (Co-Defendant III) also named in the suit.
A History of Conflicting Rulings
The legal saga began with a ruling by the Commercial Court at the Central Jakarta District Court that Agnez Mo was liable for IDR 1.5 billion (approximately $96,000 USD) for performing “Bilang Saja” without securing permission from Ari Bias. The court determined that the singer had performed the song at three separate concerts.
However, this initial ruling was overturned on appeal. The Supreme Court ultimately granted a cassation in decision number 825 K/PDT.SUS-HKI/2025, effectively reversing the lower court’s decision and offering a victory to Agnez Mo.
The Core of the Dispute: Royalties and Copyright
At the heart of the matter lies the question of royalty payments for public performances of copyrighted material. Ari Bias initially filed the lawsuit seeking compensation for the use of “Bilang Saja” in performances by Agnez Mo. The case highlights the complexities of copyright law and the importance of securing proper licensing agreements before utilizing another artist’s work.
The ongoing proceedings suggest that the legal complexities surrounding the case have not yet been fully resolved. The continued summonses for Agnez Mo indicate the court’s desire for her direct involvement in the proceedings.
The outcome of this case could set a significant precedent for copyright enforcement and royalty disputes within the Indonesian music industry, potentially impacting how artists and songwriters negotiate performance rights and compensation in the future.