Fort Jones, California – A Northern California family is drawing attention for a rather unique naming tradition: all four of their daughters are named Mary. Brian and Mary Heffernan, who left Silicon Valley life to run a ranch, have steadfastly maintained the name, a practice rooted in family history and, as they say, a bit of serendipity. The story, which began gaining traction online after a Facebook post by Mary Heffernan, has sparked both curiosity and criticism, but the couple remains resolute in their choice.
The Heffernans’ journey began with a desire for a different lifestyle. After successful careers in the tech world – Brian as an attorney and the couple jointly running eleven family-focused businesses in Menlo Park, including a farm-to-table restaurant called Bumble – they sought a life more connected to the land. This led them to Sharps Gulch Ranch in Fort Jones, a sprawling property in Siskiyou County, where they now raise beef, pork, and lamb. Their ranch, aptly named “Five Marys,” reflects the central role of the name in their family identity.
The decision to name their first daughter Mary was initially a tribute to Brian’s grandmother, who passed away around the time of her birth. “Brian and I wanted to continue the tradition with our first daughter,” Mary Heffernan wrote on Facebook. “Honestly, it never crossed our minds that all of our children would be girls. But once we started, there was no turning back.” The tradition continued with each subsequent daughter, each Mary named in honor of a different grandmother. Their daughters are Mary Frances (nicknamed Francie), Mary Marjorie (Maisie), Mary Jane (Janie), and Mary Teresa (Tessa).
A Family Rooted in Tradition
The Heffernans’ commitment to the name “Mary” stems from a long lineage of strong women on both sides of their families. According to Mary Heffernan, both her family and Brian’s have a “long history of strong Catholic women named Mary.” The name, for them, represents “humility, steadfastness, and strength,” a foundation they want to instill in their daughters. This dedication to family history is a core value that extends beyond naming conventions and into the operation of their ranch and restaurant, Five Marys Burgerhouse.
Five Marys Burgerhouse, located in Fort Jones, has become a local favorite, serving “California ranch comfort food” and, notably, their own whiskey label alongside craft beers. The restaurant building itself has a rich history, having served as a saloon during Prohibition, as reported by Yahoo Lifestyle. The Heffernans have successfully integrated their ranching expertise with the restaurant, sourcing some of the meats served directly from their farm.
Navigating Social Media Scrutiny
The family’s unique naming choice hasn’t been without its critics. A Facebook post detailing their story garnered a wave of comments, ranging from amusement to disbelief. Some commenters joked about the potential for confusion, with one remark, as reported by The Sun, suggesting the chaos of calling for “Mary” in a house full of four daughters. However, Mary Heffernan has largely dismissed the negativity, stating, “The internet always has opinions,” and emphasizing that she and Brian are “incredibly proud” of their decision.
The Heffernans have found ways to navigate the practicalities of having four daughters with the same first name. Each girl has a middle name and a nickname, providing individual distinction. “It doesn’t cause problems in everyday life,” Mary Heffernan explained, “except maybe when we’re going through airport security.”
Beyond the Names: A Ranching Life
The Heffernans’ story is more than just about a naming tradition; it’s about a deliberate shift in lifestyle and a commitment to raising their children with strong values. Leaving behind the fast-paced world of Silicon Valley, they embraced the challenges and rewards of ranching, prioritizing a connection to nature and a slower pace of life. Brian Heffernan is listed on LinkedIn as a Rancher based in Fort Jones, confirming their full-time commitment to the agricultural lifestyle.
The family’s dedication to ethical and sustainable farming practices is evident in their approach to raising livestock. The initial impetus for starting a livestock operation came from their difficulty in sourcing ethically raised meat for their restaurant, Bumble. They found that many suppliers didn’t live up to their promises of providing animals with good lives. This realization fueled their desire to create their own operation, ensuring the well-being of their animals and the quality of their products.
The Heffernans’ story resonates with a growing number of people seeking a more meaningful and sustainable way of life. Their willingness to embrace tradition while forging their own path has captured the attention of many, and their commitment to family and community is a testament to the values they hold dear.
As Five Marys continues to grow, both as a ranch and a restaurant, the Heffernans remain focused on their core principles: family, tradition, and a deep connection to the land. Future plans for the ranch include continued expansion of their livestock operations and further development of their farm-to-table offerings.
What do you reckon of the Heffernans’ unique naming tradition? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and be sure to share this story with your friends and family.
Worth a look
