The High Cost of Green Energy: Why the Western Shoshone are Fighting Nevada’s Lithium Boom
In the vast, arid stretches of northeastern Nevada, where mountain ranges meet sweeping valleys, a new kind of extraction is beginning to reshape the horizon. For Fermina Stevens, a 57-year-old member of the Te-Moak Tribe of Western Shoshone, the arrival of the “green revolution” feels less like progress and more like a repeat of a painful history. As the global demand for electric vehicle batteries surges, Stevens and her community are standing firm in their conviction: “We want to protect our Indigenous land in Nevada from the dangerous impact of lithium mining.”
The push for lithium—a critical mineral essential for the global transition to renewable energy—has ignited a fierce debate over land rights, water security, and tribal sovereignty. While policymakers frame the expansion of mining in the Great Basin as a necessity for climate goals, the Western Shoshone see a direct threat to their survival. For a community that has inhabited these lands for millennia, the promise of a cleaner future for the world must not come at the expense of the fundamental rights and resources of Indigenous peoples.
The tension in towns like Elko is palpable. Stevens, who has watched the region transform since the gold boom of the 1980s, notes that the influx of mining-related industry has fundamentally altered the social and ecological fabric of the area. As new projects move closer to ancestral territories, the Western Shoshone find themselves caught between a global energy mandate and a centuries-old struggle for recognition.
A Legacy of Broken Promises and the 1863 Treaty
The legal backbone of the Western Shoshone’s claim to their territory rests on the Ruby Valley Treaty of Peace and Friendship, signed in 1863. Unlike many historical agreements that resulted in the total cession of land, the Western Shoshone maintain that this treaty recognized their territory without requiring them to relinquish sovereignty. While the agreement granted the United States certain rights, such as the ability to explore for minerals, the community asserts that they never gave up ownership of the land itself.
The Western Shoshone Defense Project, established by elders Carrie and Mary Dann, has spent decades challenging the federal government’s management of these lands. The project’s fight is centered on the principle that the United States has failed to uphold its end of the 1863 agreement. This legal struggle has moved beyond domestic courts, reaching international human rights bodies.
Both the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination have previously determined that the human rights of the Western Shoshone were being violated by the U.S. Government. Central to these findings is the issue of “meaningful consultation”—a legal obligation the federal government has to engage with sovereign Tribes before authorizing activities on their lands.
Stevens argues that the current process is often a hollow formality. She observes that the government frequently delegates the responsibility of consultation to the very corporations seeking to profit from the extraction, rather than engaging directly with the sovereign nations whose land is at stake.
The Ecological Toll: Water, Food, and Cumulative Impact
Beyond the legal battles lies a more immediate, physical threat to the Shoshone way of life. The environmental impact of lithium extraction is particularly concerning in Nevada, which is already recognized as one of the driest states in the U.S. Unlike gold mining, lithium extraction is notoriously water-intensive, a factor that poses an existential risk to communities already grappling with chronic drought.
The threat extends to the very flora that sustains the community. Stevens highlights the destruction of pinyon trees, which are essential for the harvesting of pine nuts—a traditional staple and vital food source for the Western Shoshone. The loss of these trees represents not just an ecological shift, but a severance of a cultural and nutritional lifeline that has existed for thousands of years.
| Impact Factor | Gold Mining (Historical) | Lithium Mining (Emerging) |
|---|---|---|
| Water Consumption | High | Significantly Higher |
| Land Use | Localized extraction | Large-scale land occupation |
| Traditional Food Sources | Moderate disruption | High risk (e.g., Pinyon trees) |
| Cumulative Pollution | Established in soil/water | Exacerbates existing pollution |
The concern is not merely about the new projects, but the cumulative effect of nearly 200 years of extraction in Nevada. Since mining began in the region in the 1840s, the ground and water supplies have faced continuous pressure from various mineral extractions. Stevens warns that lithium mining will only exacerbate the existing pollution and resource depletion that the community is already living through.
Looking Toward the Next Century
For the leadership of the Western Shoshone Defense Project, the struggle is not about the present moment alone, but about the viability of their culture in the decades to come. The decision-making happening today regarding lithium permits will dictate whether future generations can continue to practice their spirituality and maintain their connection to the land.
“We’re thinking 40, 60, 80 years from now,” Stevens says. “Will we even be able to practise our spirituality because of the poisoning that is happening to our land and to the water?”
As the lithium boom continues to accelerate, the Western Shoshone remain committed to a philosophy of kinship—not just with each other, but with the Earth itself. They argue that true humanity requires finding common ground that respects the limits of the natural world and the sovereignty of its original stewards.
The next phase of this conflict will likely unfold in federal regulatory offices and international human rights forums as the community seeks to force a more rigorous adherence to treaty obligations and environmental protections. For now, the eyes of the Indigenous rights movement remain fixed on the high deserts of Nevada.
If you found this report important, please share it with your network to help bring visibility to Indigenous land rights and the complexities of the global energy transition. We welcome your thoughts and comments in the section below.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or environmental professional advice.
Keep reading
