Angels Reach Settlement with Skaggs Family in Wrongful Death Suit
Table of Contents
A last-minute settlement was reached Friday between the Los Angeles Angels and the family of the late pitcher Tyler Skaggs, averting a verdict after jurors signaled they were leaning toward finding the team culpable in his death. The financial terms of the agreement remain undisclosed, concluding a years-long legal battle stemming from the tragic loss of Skaggs in 2019.
The lawsuit originated from the circumstances surrounding Skaggs’ death, where an Angels employee, Eric Kay, provided him with a fentanyl-laced pill. Kay is currently serving a 22-year federal prison sentence for his role in the incident. Jurors were instructed that, absent Kay’s actions, Skaggs would likely have survived.
Jury Deliberations Pointed to Team Liability
Negotiations intensified on Thursday,according to sources,and culminated in Friday’s settlement as the jury entered its third day of deliberations.Prior to the agreement,the jury had submitted questions to the court indicating a potential inclination toward holding the Angels accountable. specifically, jurors inquired about the testimony of five wage experts who estimated Skaggs’ lost career earnings between $21 million and nearly $125 million, as well as the possibility of awarding punitive damages.
The trial itself spanned 31 days, featuring testimony and depositions from 44 witnesses and the presentation of 312 exhibits. The jury faced a complex set of 26 questions, requiring agreement from at least nine of the twelve jurors on each point. Ultimately, the jury was never asked to deliver a verdict or assign percentages of responsibility.
Conflicting arguments at the Heart of the Case
Throughout the proceedings, the Angels, represented by lead attorney Todd Theodora, maintained that Kay acted independently and that the institution was unaware of his illicit activities. Theodora argued it was “undisputed in this case that Eric was doing this on his own.”
However, attorneys for the Skaggs family, led by Daniel Dutko, presented evidence suggesting the Angels were aware of Kay’s drug problem. Dutko highlighted a Drug Enforcement Agency interview where Kay reportedly admitted to informing his superior in 2017 about his and Skaggs’ drug use. The family contended that the Angels failed to adequately address Kay’s substance abuse, creating a risky surroundings that contributed to Skaggs’ death. “We’ve spent two months in trial,” dutko stated during his closing argument. “At any point have the Angels taken any responsibility?”
Angels Claimed Lack of Knowledge, Skaggs’ Prior Addiction
The Angels also asserted they were unaware of Skaggs’ own prior addiction to Percocet, claiming he concealed it from the team, even from his wife. Theodora stated the team signed skaggs “under false pretenses” due to this undisclosed history. The defense further argued that kay was not acting within the scope of his employment when he provided the fatal pill and that the Angels were not responsible for Skaggs’ “reckless decisions.”
The settlement brings an end to a highly publicized an
Why: Tyler Skaggs died from a fentanyl overdose. The lawsuit centered on whether the Angels organization bore responsibility for creating a situation that led to his death.
Who: The lawsuit was between the family of Tyler Skaggs and the Los Angeles Angels. Key individuals included Eric Kay (who provided the pill), todd Theodora (Angels’ attorney), and Daniel Dutko (Skaggs’ family attorney).
What: The Skaggs family sued the Angels, alleging negligence and wrongful death. The core argument was whether the Angels knew about, or should have known about, Eric
