A Dallas resident described feeling pressured to maintain youthfulness, revealing how anti-ageing culture exacerbates body image struggles among middle-aged women, according to a study commissioned by the Butterfly Foundation.
“You don’t know what it’s like here,” she said. Everyone has a facelift if they can afford one.
Cultural Pressures and the Rise of Anti-Ageing Obsession
Anthropologist Dr. Sarah Lamb’s research underscores this trend, noting that while many embrace “successful ageing” as a goal, the pressure to conform to youth-centric ideals often leads to frustration. The author notes that lurking behind all these hypermodern anti-ageing claims is the same old ageism.
SMH and The Age both cite data from the Butterfly Foundation’s study, which surveyed 1,005 Australians. It found that body confidence declines with age, with 20 per cent of Gen Z and Gen Y respondents feeling “very confident” about their bodies, compared to just 9 per cent of those aged 61 to 80. While men were twice as likely to say they feel very confident, women were twice as likely to say they felt “very under-confident”, the research found. Clare Loewenthal, who spent much of her career as a business writer, emphasizes that these pressures are compounded by the rise of the “longevity movement” and anti-ageing supplements industry.
Historical Shifts in Age Stereotypes
Historical analysis reveals that perceptions of aging have shifted dramatically over centuries. In the 1600s and 1700s, older adults were revered, as detailed in sociologist and ageing expert Dr. Deborah Carr’s 2023 book Aging in America. By the mid-1800s, derogatory terms like “old coot” became common.
This historical context aligns with modern concerns about how scientific advancements in anti-ageing – from skincare to longevity research – are redefining societal expectations.
Expert Insights on Body Image and Aging
Professor Jayashri Kulkarni, director of Monash University’s HER Centre and a women’s mental health expert, highlights how hormonal changes in midlife can exacerbate body image concerns. “As the protective psychological effect of female sex hormones recedes in midlife, women who have had previous issues with eating disorders or other mental health problems might experience recurrence,” she explains. The Butterfly Foundation study also notes that “grey divorce” – the rising rate of separations among older women – contributes to heightened anxiety about appearance.
Meanwhile, the Butterfly Foundation’s data shows a decline in body confidence among older women compared to younger generations, raising alarms about the long-term mental health impacts of anti-ageing culture.
The Paradox of Age-Defying Role Models
While the visibility of older models and fitness influencers has grown, experts warn that this trend can create new pressures. “Comparison is an issue across age groups,” Kulkarni says. “Increased visibility of age-defying role models puts extra pressure on older women.” This paradox is evident in the Dallas resident’s story, who admits, “I’m saving up to get my neck done,” despite recognizing the societal undercurrents driving her desire to alter her appearance.
The analysis also references a 2023 book by Dr. Deborah Carr, which argues that older adults were once revered in societies where they made up just 2% of the population. “Fashionable people often aged themselves and lied about being older for social prestige,” Carr writes. This historical contrast underscores the current tension between scientific progress and ageist attitudes, as anti-ageing culture blurs the line between self-care and societal pressure.
As anti-ageing culture continues to evolve, researchers and advocates warn of its potential to deepen ageist divides. The Butterfly Foundation’s study calls for greater awareness of how societal expectations shape body image, particularly among older women.
The analysis suggests that the push for “successful ageing” risks creating a new form of exclusion. As the debate over ageing and self-perception intensifies, the challenge will be to balance scientific innovation with a more inclusive, compassionate view of aging.
“You don’t know what it’s like here,” said a Dallas resident, describing the pressure to maintain youthfulness in her community. Everyone has a facelift if they can afford one.
While men were twice as likely to say they feel very confident, women were twice as likely to say they felt “very under-confident”, according to the Butterfly Foundation study.
The Guardian reported on the cultural pressures driving anti-ageing obsessions, while SMH and Theage highlighted the Butterfly Foundation’s findings on declining body confidence among older women.
Find more reporting in our Health section.
Related reading
