UK Budget 2024: Rachel Reeves Faces Mounting Pressure to Address £50 Billion Financial Gap
Table of Contents
The UK Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, has announced the Autumn Budget will take place on Wednesday, November 26th, as she prepares to outline the government’s plans for taxation and spending amidst a challenging economic landscape. Reeves confirmed the date, signaling a pivotal moment for the nation’s finances as she navigates pressures to bolster economic growth, maintain investor confidence, and address a potential £50 billion gap in public finances.
Balancing Act: Growth, Debt, and Investor Confidence
The upcoming Budget arrives as Reeves faces a complex balancing act. Economists warn that tax increases or spending cuts are likely necessary to maintain the Chancellor’s borrowing rules, particularly given sluggish economic growth and rising inflation – the rate at which prices increase. Speaking exclusively to the BBC, Reeves acknowledged the need for decisive action, stating, “Do I accept that we need to do more to turn the economy around so that working people have the tools and the training and the opportunities to fulfil their potential? Absolutely we do.”
Her second Budget will prioritize “investing in our economy and ensuring that working people wherever they live in our country are better off,” she added.
Labour’s election manifesto included a pledge not to raise taxes on “working people,” specifically excluding increases to Value Added Tax (VAT), National Insurance (NI), and income tax. However, last year’s Budget saw an increase in NI contributions for employers, sparking criticism from businesses, particularly within the hospitality sector. This has fueled speculation regarding potential tax increases, with suggestions ranging from a windfall tax on bank profits to reforms of the council tax system and levies on property.
Adding to the financial strain, long-term borrowing costs have reached their highest level since 1998, consuming a significant portion of the government’s limited financial buffer – estimated at around £10 billion.
OBR Forecast and Market Stability
Reeves has tasked the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the government’s independent economic forecaster, with producing a new economic forecast based on her policies. This 10-week process is crucial, as the OBR’s assessment is seen as a key factor in maintaining stability in financial markets and ensuring continued investor confidence in the UK economy. Some economists previously advocated for an earlier, expedited Budget in October to resolve the uncertainty surrounding potential policy changes, but the government opted for the November timeframe to allow for a comprehensive review.
Investment, Reform, and Key Challenges
The government has highlighted recent positive steps, including increases to the minimum wage, reductions in NHS waiting times, and planning system reforms aimed at facilitating the construction of 1.5 million homes in England. Reeves emphasized the need to “bring inflation and borrowing costs down by keeping a tight grip on day to day spending through our non-negotiable fiscal rules,” framing investment and reform as the tools for achieving “renewal” and economic growth.
However, opposition voices remain critical. Shadow chancellor Mel Stride accused Labour of “stalling,” arguing that the delayed Budget prolongs uncertainty. “Labour don’t have a plan – and they don’t know what they’re doing,” Stride stated.
“Decision Time” for the UK Economy
Lord Jim O’Neill, a former Goldman Sachs chief economist who has advised both Labour and the Conservatives, described the current moment as “decision time” for the Prime Minister and Chancellor. He identified several critical areas requiring attention, including the pension triple lock, the housing market, welfare reform, and NHS productivity. “The markets are now at the point where something needs to happen on that big stuff because you can’t keep going along tampering along at the margin,” he told the BBC.
Treasury sources maintain that the end of November aligns with the typical timing for an Autumn budgetary statement, allowing sufficient time for the full process involving the OBR. The initial stage involves the OBR delivering a new baseline forecast, incorporating an assessment of long-term productivity, which could further exacerbate the challenges in the public finances, particularly given recent U-turns on welfare cuts and rising borrowing costs. The OBR will then advise the Treasury on the necessary tax increases or spending cuts to meet Reeves’ borrowing rules.
Non-Negotiable Borrowing Rules
Reeves has established two “non-negotiable” rules regarding government borrowing: ensuring day-to-day government costs are covered by tax income by 2029-30, and reducing debt as a share of national income by the end of the current parliament in 2029-30.
Recent analysis from the National Institute for Economics and Social Research suggests the public finances gap could reach £50 billion annually, underscoring the need for a substantial financial buffer to avoid breaching these self-imposed rules. Rising global borrowing costs, driven by political uncertainty, high debt levels, and shifts in pension fund investments, further complicate the situation.
Economist Mohamed El-Erian, president of Queen’s College at Cambridge University, believes tax rises are inevitable. “At the end of the day there’s only three ways to deal with a fiscal issue: You raise revenue, you cut expenditure, or you borrow more. The government has made it clear that it will not borrow more,” he explained. “We’ve already cut expenditure quite a bit… So it looks increasingly like she’ll [Reeves] have to increase taxes and increasingly it looks like she may have to resort to certain taxes that she ruled out.”
Ultimately, the Chancellor faces the daunting task of balancing the books, securing support for her policies within her party, and implementing reforms to stimulate sluggish economic growth.
