Four African American patients underwent repeat colonoscopies within 12 months of their initial procedures, according to a case series reported by Cureus.
A review of five patients at a single academic hospital-based endoscopy unit examined if these short-interval repeats followed clinical guidance.
Some procedures were appropriate. Others fell into an indeterminate category because medical documentation was incomplete.
The appropriateness of these repeats is often difficult to establish after the fact, the Cureus report said.
In two instances, the repeat examinations were supported. These occurred at six and seven months following index procedures where doctors documented poor visualization or suboptimal preparation.
Other cases were indeterminate. The medical records did not explicitly link the specific examination to the procedural rationale or the completeness of the previous resection.
The assessment of these patients used various standards, including 2012 and 2020 guidance.
In the United States, colorectal cancer (CRC) incidence was 41.7 per 100,000 among Black individuals between 2015 and 2019. This was higher than the 35.7 per 100,000 recorded among White individuals. Black individuals also showed higher mortality.
The case series found that records did not consistently document Boston Bowel Preparation Scale (BBPS) scores and withdrawal times.
The clinical team identified the five patients in the Cureus case series rather than using a systematic search. Because of this, the total number of eligible patients and the total number of colonoscopies performed during the period are unknown.
The cases are not consecutive or representative. They are reported for illustrative purposes only. The colonoscopies were performed between 2010 and 2021.
Sekiguchi, H. Takamaru, et al.
The study analyzed 22,066 colonoscopies after applying exclusion criteria.
Researchers excluded examinations for known lesions, inflammatory bowel disease, unclear indications, or an unclear history of prior colonoscopy. They also excluded patients with a history of colonoscopy within the previous 6 months.
If medical records or referral letters could not determine a patient’s history of prior lesions with certainty, they were excluded.
The analysis used colonoscopic examinations as the unit of analysis instead of individual patients. Repeated colonoscopies from the same patient were included as separate examinations. ANDR and baseline characteristics were analyzed on a per-colonoscopy basis.
The primary outcome was ANDR. Surveillance intervals were considered appropriate when the ANDR was ≤7%.
The ANDR was 17.4% at the first-ever examination. The rate declined as the number of recent colonoscopies rose.
The rate was 7.2% for those with no colonoscopy in the previous five years. It fell to 3.9% after one, 3.4% after two, and 2.3% following three or more exams.
In patients without prior lesions or with only non-advanced adenomas, the ANDR remained ≤7% within an interval of five years or longer before the index colonoscopy.
| Patient Group | Recent Colonoscopy Frequency | ANDR (%) |
|---|---|---|
| First-ever colonoscopies | N/A | 17.4 |
| No colonoscopy in 5 years | 0 | 7.2 |
| One colonoscopy in 5 years | 1 | 3.9 |
| Two colonoscopies in 5 years | 2 | 3.4 |
| Three or more in 5 years | 3+ | 2.3 |
Screening, surveillance, and positive fecal immunochemical test results were the main indications for these examinations, the study said. A family history of colorectal cancer was present in 9.9% of patients.
The findings were published by Cureus, a web-based medical journal that originally began as PeerEMed in 2009. The journal is known for an unusually fast peer-review process and utilizes a trademarked Scholarly Impact Quotient to incorporate peer opinions after an article has been published.
People seeking information about colorectal health or surveillance intervals must consult a qualified medical professional.