Netflix’s ‘Death by Lightning’ Delivers a Sharp Historical Drama Amidst Blockbuster Hype
Table of Contents
A compelling new series from Netflix, Death by Lightning, is quietly captivating viewers with its nuanced portrayal of a pivotal moment in American history, offering a refreshing alternative to the current focus on shows like Stranger Things and Adolescence. The four-episode limited series doesn’t demand a significant time commitment, yet it masterfully utilizes every minute with sharp writing, stellar performances, and meticulous production design.
A President Cut Down: The Story of James A. Garfield
Set in the late 19th century, Death by Lightning centers on the election and tragically short presidency of James A. Garfield (Michael Shannon) and his subsequent assassination at the hands of Charles J. Guiteau (Matthew Macfadyen). The series unfolds against a backdrop of a fractured Republican Party grappling with its future, with Garfield emerging as an unlikely frontrunner after a passionate speech advocating for James Blaine. His appeal stemmed from a perceived potential for change, resonating with party members drawn to his compassion and morality.
However, the narrative doesn’t solely focus on the president. It dedicates significant attention to the life of Guiteau, a man described as a devoted “Stan” for Garfield – a delusional and desperate individual who ingratiates himself into the lives of others while relentlessly pursuing personal recognition. According to one observer, Macfadyen delivers an “absolute scene-stealing” performance as Guiteau, embodying the character’s ambition, desperation, corruption, and delusion with unsettling accuracy. He is, as the source material notes, “like that wad of gum you can’t get out from under your shoe, no matter how hard you try.”
A Stellar Supporting Cast Brings History to Life
The strength of Death by Lightning extends beyond its central figures, boasting a remarkable ensemble cast. Nick Offerman portrays Vice President Chester A. Arthur, a man whose loyalty to Garfield is compromised by his business dealings with Roscoe Conkling (Shea Whigham). Offerman’s Arthur is presented as ill-suited for office, openly admitting his shortcomings while grappling with a lack of ambition. Betty Gilpin embodies Lucretia Garfield, and Bradley Whitford takes on the role of James Blaine, rounding out a cast that breathes life into this historical period.
Production Design and Unexpected Humor
The production design is a standout element of the series, seamlessly transporting viewers to the 1880s. The costumes, sets, and even the CG backdrops create an immersive experience, often resembling the detailed photographs of bustling city streets from that era. Remarkably, despite its somber subject matter, the show incorporates surprising moments of humor. As one source points out, Death by Lightning functions as a political satire, skillfully avoiding absurdity while delivering clever wit.
Much of this wit is attributed to Macfadyen’s portrayal of Guiteau, a character who is simultaneously a bumbling fool, a con artist, and a self-proclaimed visionary. He is, the source material emphasizes, “never wrong, even though he’s always in the wrong.”
A Worthy Addition to the Historical Drama Landscape
For viewers who appreciate period pieces, clever writing, and compelling historical dramas, Death by Lightning is a highly recommended watch. Its concise four-episode format ensures a focused narrative, delivering a powerful message without unnecessary digressions. While the story is complete, one reviewer expressed a desire for additional episodes, highlighting the show’s captivating nature and the richness of the historical context.
