Brussels – A sense of unease is growing across Europe regarding the European Union’s standing on the world stage. While still widely seen as a significant global economic and political force, new data reveals a wavering confidence in the bloc’s ability to effectively navigate an increasingly unstable geopolitical landscape. This shift in perception, fueled by diverging views on crises like the war in Ukraine and the conflict in Gaza, alongside a cooling relationship with the United States, is prompting calls for a more self-reliant and assertive EU.
A recent survey by Euroconsumers, encompassing nearly 10,000 respondents across ten member states – Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Poland, Portugal and Spain – provides a detailed snapshot of European sentiment. The findings suggest a growing disconnect between the EU’s economic strength and its perceived capacity for decisive action in a world grappling with complex challenges. Understanding Euroconsumers’ methodology is key to interpreting the data, as it focuses on consumer perceptions across these key nations.
A Recognised Power, But With Limitations
The EU continues to be broadly recognized as a major player. Approximately 63% of Europeans view the bloc as a leading economic power, and 60% spot it as an influential political actor. This perception is largely rooted in the EU’s substantial economic weight and its role in setting global standards in areas like trade and environmental regulation. Though, the survey highlights a significant gap when it comes to military capabilities. Only 36% of respondents believe the EU is a credible “hard power,” underscoring a perceived weakness in its ability to project force and defend its interests.
This disparity is particularly evident when examining views on specific international crises. While 42% of those surveyed believe the EU has demonstrated strong leadership in response to the war in Ukraine – a conflict that has prompted unprecedented levels of EU unity and sanctions against Russia – a nearly identical 41% feel the EU has failed to provide effective leadership in addressing the ongoing crisis in Gaza. This divergence suggests a lack of consensus on how the EU should respond to conflicts outside of its immediate neighborhood.
Internal divisions within the EU are consistently identified as a major impediment to its global influence. Roughly two-thirds of respondents cite disagreements between member states as undermining the bloc’s ability to act decisively on the world stage. This fragmentation, often stemming from differing national interests and priorities, hinders the EU’s capacity to forge a unified foreign policy.
A Cooling Transatlantic Relationship and a Search for New Partnerships
The survey also reveals a growing skepticism towards the United States as a reliable long-term partner. Just 28% of respondents believe Washington will remain a dependable ally in the years ahead. This decline in trust is particularly pronounced in Denmark, Germany, Portugal, Ireland, Belgium, and Spain, where significant portions of the population express doubts about the durability of the transatlantic alliance. This shift is likely influenced by recent geopolitical events, including the Trump administration’s questioning of traditional alliances and the current US approach to trade and security commitments.
In response to this perceived waning of US reliability, approximately half of respondents believe the EU should prioritize building new partnerships beyond the United States. A majority – 51% – support deepening trade relations with Asian economies like Japan and South Korea, while 37% favor closer economic ties with China. This signals a desire for greater diversification of partnerships and a reduced reliance on any single global power. The Council on Foreign Relations’ Global Conflict Tracker provides ongoing analysis of geopolitical tensions influencing these perceptions.
Trade tensions with the US are also a significant factor shaping European attitudes. A substantial 70% of respondents support EU countermeasures in response to US tariffs, demonstrating a willingness to defend European economic interests even at the risk of escalating trade disputes. Opinions are divided, however, on how Brussels has handled the policies of former President Donald Trump, with 38% disapproving of the EU’s response and 34% expressing support.
Consumer behavior is also reflecting this shift in sentiment. Around 44% of Europeans report having reduced or stopped buying American products, a figure that rises to 55% in Denmark. This suggests a growing willingness among consumers to align their purchasing decisions with their political views.
Calls for Greater Autonomy and Technological Independence
The survey underscores strong support for a more self-reliant European Union. Approximately 80% of respondents back increased investment in European technology to reduce dependence on external powers. This reflects a growing recognition of the strategic importance of technological sovereignty and a desire to avoid being overly reliant on foreign suppliers, particularly in critical areas like semiconductors and artificial intelligence. The EU has already launched initiatives like the Digital Decade policy program to bolster its technological capabilities.
There is also broad backing for strengthening European defence capabilities and diversifying trade partnerships. However, expectations remain measured. While many Europeans favor a more assertive EU on the global stage, concerns about the potential economic impact of such a shift persist, particularly as households continue to grapple with rising living costs and economic uncertainty. The ongoing energy crisis, exacerbated by the war in Ukraine, has further heightened these concerns.
The path forward for the EU involves navigating these complex challenges while forging a unified vision for its role in the world. The survey data suggests a growing desire for greater autonomy, strategic diversification, and a more assertive foreign policy, but also a recognition of the economic constraints and internal divisions that could hinder its progress. The EU’s ability to address these challenges will be crucial in determining its future influence on the global stage.
Looking ahead, the European Council is scheduled to discuss defense and security policy at its next meeting in December. This meeting will be a key indicator of the EU’s commitment to strengthening its military capabilities and addressing the concerns raised by the Euroconsumers survey. Further developments will likely be shared on the European Council’s official website.
What do you think about the EU’s global role? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and please share this article with your network.
