A former anti-crime brigade officer in Seine-Saint-Denis was sentenced on Friday to eighteen months in prison without a warrant of commitment after being found guilty of fatally shooting a motorist during a 2022 traffic stop, Lemonde reported.
The criminal court of Seine-Saint-Denis handed down a five-year prison sentence with three and a half years suspended, falling significantly short of the five-year criminal prison term with a deferred warrant requested by the prosecutor general (Le Monde).
The verdict provoked angry and despairing outbursts from the family of the victim, Jean-Paul Benjamin, and local residents inside the courtroom in Bobigny and its lobby (Le Monde). This gives an idea of what they consider a man's life to be worth, stated Me Philippe-Henry Honegger, one of the family’s lawyers.
The incident occurred around midday on March 26, 2022, in Aulnay-sous-Bois. Jean-Paul Benjamin, a 33-year-old delivery driver born in French Guiana to Haitian parents (Le Monde), was driving a van reported as stolen that was being tracked discreetly by a marked police vehicle (Le Monde). Radio dispatches had described the driver as being of African descent (Le Monde).

Reinforcements were called to conduct a control, prompting Emmanuel Neves, a 37-year-old anti-crime brigade brigadier-chef, to arrive in a separate vehicle (Le Monde). Operating in plainclothes without a police armband, Neves emerged and ran alone toward the driver’s door (Le Monde).
The intervention lasted less than three seconds before he fired (Le Monde). The bullet penetrated the bodywork and struck the motorist in the liver (Le Monde). Although the driver managed to drive a short distance away to his housing estate in Sevran, he subsequently died at the hospital (Le Monde).
During the trial, Neves was tried for violence resulting in death without intent to cause it (Le Monde).

He argued self-defense, maintaining that he feared for his physical integrity because the van’s motor was revving and he worried it would pull away while he stood beside the door (Le Monde). "Je tire parce que mon intégrité physique est engagée. C’est un tir de riposte," Neves stated to the court (Le Monde). His defense attorney, Me Thibault de Montbrial, requested an acquittal.
The five judges of the criminal court reviewed municipal closed-circuit television footage multiple times and rejected the self-defense claim (Le Monde). Prosecutor Fanny Bussac had argued during proceedings that the officer was never threatened by the vehicle. Court president Caroline Jadis-Pomeau explained that while determining the sentence, the judges factored in the defendant’s excellent service record (Le Monde).
Located in the Île-de-France region, Seine-Saint-Denis is often referred to colloquially as quatre-vingt-treize or neuf trois after its official administrative number, 93. In 2018, the department had the highest crime rate in metropolitan France, with a poverty rate twice the national average at 28%.
In addition to the prison term, the court issued a permanent ban preventing Neves from working as a police officer and prohibited him from carrying a weapon for five years (Le Monde). Whether further legal challenges or appeals will follow from either side remains unstated.