The Federal Communications Commission ordered California on Thursday to stop enforcing its carrier-of-last-resort rules against AT&T, clearing the way for the carrier to end landline service for roughly 184,000 residential and 15,000 business customers on June 1, 2027.
FCC Preemption Order
California is the only state in AT&T’s 21-state wireline footprint where the company has not received relief from carrier-of-last-resort obligations. A federal judge rejected AT&T’s attempt to override the state rules in July. The FCC’s decision may not be final; California has signaled it could sue the commission.
California Delegation Letter
United States Representatives Jimmy Panetta (CA-19), Doris Matsui (CA-07), and Mike Thompson (CA-04) warned in a letter that the draft order circulated to the Commission on October 30, 2026, purports to preempt the California Public Utilities Commission’s Carrier of Last Resort rules.
These rules obligate telecommunications carriers to furnish basic phone service to any customer in their territory who asks for it, guaranteeing that no Californian goes without essential communications, including 911. The lawmakers wrote, “These rules require telecommunications companies to provide basic phone service to anyone within their service area who requests it, ensuring that no Californian is left without access to essential communications services, including 911.”
The California Public Utilities Commission is currently conducting a proceeding to modernize its carrier-of-last-resort framework. Gomez argued the FCC should have allowed that process to finish, saying significant technology transitions work best “when the state regulator is a partner with a real role,” not treated “as an obstacle to be cleared.”
“are often the last line of defense for consumers. They know their communities, they take their complaints, and they answer to the people who rely on these services in a way that a federal agency in Washington cannot always match,” FCC Commissioner Anna Gomez said.
Wireless Replacement Standards
AT&T says a wireless home phone service that connects to the cellular network will replace the copper lines. The FCC agreed that the IP-based alternative is sufficient in the authorized areas.
California says its rules do permit wireless replacements, but only if the carrier demonstrates the service meets state standards — including flat-rate unlimited calling, discounted Lifeline rates for low-income households, and telephone relay service for people who are deaf or hard of hearing.
Lawmakers from the California delegation warned in a November 16 letter that the preemption would eliminate the state’s ability to require proof that replacements work before copper is retired, affecting rural communities and elderly populations most at risk. They asked the FCC to respond to a list of questions by December 15, 2026, before any vote on the draft order.
Broader Conflict Revived
The order also revives a broader conflict: during the first Trump administration, the FCC failed in 2019 to preempt California’s net neutrality law, and the state prevailed in court. Now California faces a potential tradeoff between upholding its telecom regulations and receiving $1.42 billion in federal broadband funding for 270,571 locations.
This month, the Commission is permitting copper retirement to commence in eighteen states — Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Wisconsin. Those customers’ experiences over time may be helpful in determining the adequacy of wireless replacements.
However, these efforts must be carried out with care, in a way that safeguards vulnerable communities during emergencies and outages and preserves universal telephone service for all Americans.
AT&T traces its history to the American Telephone and Telegraph Company, formed in 1885 as a long-distance subsidiary of American Bell Telephone. For much of the 20th century it held a natural monopoly over U.S. telephony under the Bell System, earning the nickname “Ma Bell.”
The Justice Department sued under the Sherman Antitrust Act, and in 1982 AT&T agreed to break up the Bell System into seven independent “Baby Bells.” The modern AT&T emerged in 2005 when SBC Communications, the smallest Baby Bell, acquired AT&T Corporation and adopted its name. Today the company serves over 240 million subscribers worldwide and is the nation’s largest fiber internet provider.
California must still decide whether to sue the FCC over the preemption.