A Tampa jury on Friday found four men guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder in the targeted killing of Jacksonville rapper Foolio. The verdict, delivered after eight hours of deliberation, concludes a month-long trial that detailed a coordinated “mission” to execute the artist while he was celebrating his birthday in Florida’s Gulf Coast region.
The convicted men—Isaiah Chance, Sean Gathright, Rashad Murphy, and Davion Murphy—were found responsible for the June 23, 2024, ambush that left the rapper dead and several others wounded. The proceedings revealed a calculated effort to stalk the victim, culminating in a hail of gunfire outside a Tampa Holiday Inn.
The case serves as a grim milestone in a years-long cycle of violence linked to Jacksonville’s gang landscape, specifically involving the conflict surrounding the “6 Block” set. Prosecutors successfully argued that the killing was not a random act of violence but a gang-sanctioned execution intended to eliminate a high-profile rival.
The Ambush at the Holiday Inn
The evidence presented during the trial painted a picture of a professional-style hit. According to court testimony and surveillance footage, the defendants tracked Foolio’s movements as he spent his birthday weekend in Tampa. The prosecution established that the group operated as a cell, with some providing intelligence and others serving as the shooters.
Surveillance video played for the jury showed Gathright, Rashad Murphy, and Davion Murphy unloading automatic weapons into a parked car where the rapper was sitting. The sheer volume of fire was described by investigators as an attempt to ensure the target did not survive. The state proved that Isaiah Chance and his then-girlfriend, Alicia Andrews, acted as the architects of the operation, providing the shooters with the rapper’s precise location.
In addition to the murder charges, the jury convicted Gathright and both Murphys of attempted second-degree murder for the injuries sustained by other individuals caught in the crossfire. The jury also agreed that the state proved Chance and the Murphys were active members of a gang and that the shooting was directly tied to gang activities, a finding that may carry significant weight during the upcoming sentencing phase.
| Defendant | Primary Conviction | Additional Findings |
|---|---|---|
| Isaiah Chance | 1st Degree Murder | Conspiracy, Gang Activity |
| Sean Gathright | 1st Degree Murder | Conspiracy, Attempted 2nd Degree Murder |
| Rashad Murphy | 1st Degree Murder | Conspiracy, Attempted 2nd Degree Murder, Gang Activity |
| Davion Murphy | 1st Degree Murder | Conspiracy, Attempted 2nd Degree Murder, Gang Activity |
The Role of Alicia Andrews
While the four men faced the bulk of the murder charges in this trial, the prosecution’s case relied heavily on the involvement of Alicia Andrews. Andrews, the fifth person charged in the conspiracy, was convicted of manslaughter in a separate trial last November.
Investigators established that Andrews worked in tandem with Isaiah Chance to facilitate the hit. While she did not pull a trigger, her role in coordinating the rapper’s whereabouts was deemed essential to the execution of the crime. She currently remains in custody awaiting her final sentencing.
The Legal Stakes: Death Penalty Seeked
The legal battle now shifts from the question of guilt to the question of punishment. In Florida, first-degree murder convictions can carry the death penalty, provided the state can prove specific aggravating factors—such as the premeditated nature of the crime or the involvement of a gang.
The prosecution has formally indicated its intent to request that the jury recommend the death penalty for all four defendants. The state will likely argue that the brazen nature of the attack—carried out in a public parking lot with automatic weapons—demonstrates a callous disregard for human life and public safety.
Impact and Context
The death of Foolio is seen by many in the Jacksonville community as a symptom of a deeper, more systemic conflict. The rapper’s music often chronicled the realities of street life and specific neighborhood rivalries, which some argue blurred the line between artistic expression and real-world targeting.
For the families of the victims and the community at large, the verdict provides a measure of legal closure, though it does little to erase the trauma of the event. The trial highlighted the increasing use of digital tracking and social media to coordinate violent crimes, as the defendants used real-time information to corner their target.
Disclaimer: This report covers legal proceedings involving violent crime. For those affected by gang violence or seeking support for grief and trauma, resources are available through the National Center for Victims of Crime at victimservices.org.
The penalty phase of the trial is scheduled to begin on Monday, May 11. This phase will involve testimony regarding the defendants’ backgrounds and the impact of the crime on the victims’ families before the jury decides between life imprisonment or the death penalty.
We invite you to share your thoughts on this verdict in the comments below and share this story to keep the community informed.
