Seven in ten adults with health insurance in Ireland have never switched providers or plans, a new study reveals, highlighting a remarkable level of inertia in a market facing rising costs and increasing consumer dissatisfaction. The research, conducted by the Health Insurance Authority (HIA) and IPSOS, indicates that a significant majority of policyholders remain with the same insurer for extended periods, often decades, despite annual premium increases. This lack of movement raises questions about consumer awareness, the perceived complexity of switching, and the effectiveness of competition within the Irish health insurance landscape.
The IPSOS HIA consumer survey, completed last year, found that 82% of consumers do not shop around for better deals when their health insurance is up for renewal. On average, individuals stay with the same health insurance plan for 20 years, a figure that underscores the long-term commitment – and potential lack of engagement – among Irish health insurance customers. The findings come as average health insurance premiums in Ireland rose from €1,827 to €1,902 last year, according to the HIA, with some individuals experiencing considerably larger increases. Despite these rising costs, and broader cost-of-living pressures, switching rates remain stubbornly low.
Satisfaction and Perceived Savings: Why Consumers Stay Put
The primary driver behind this loyalty appears to be satisfaction with existing coverage. The HIA study found that high satisfaction was the most commonly cited reason for not switching. Still, a significant portion of consumers also believe that potential savings from switching would be limited. This perception, even in the face of documented premium hikes, suggests a lack of confidence in finding more affordable options or a belief that the effort involved in switching outweighs any potential financial benefit. Interestingly, the research indicates that consumers now typically require a cost saving of around 20% to consider switching, a decrease from 22% in 2023, 30% in 2021, and 30% in 2019, suggesting a growing willingness to consider alternatives, albeit at a more substantial discount.
The data reveals a limited amount of activity even among those who *do* consider a change. Only 4% of customers switched providers last year, and just 15% switched plans with their existing provider. This suggests that whereas some consumers are evaluating their options, the barriers to actually making a change remain significant. The HIA acknowledges this disconnect between rising premiums and low switching rates, particularly given the current economic climate.
A Growing Number Question Premium Increases, and Some Cancel Coverage
Consumer sentiment regarding premium increases is increasingly negative. The HIA survey found that nearly half of respondents (46%) believe recent premium increases are not justified, marking the highest level of dissatisfaction in a decade. This dissatisfaction is reflected in a rising number of policy cancellations. Almost one in five people who currently do not have health insurance previously held a policy but cancelled it – the highest lapse rate in over a decade. Cost remains the overwhelming reason cited by consumers for not holding or giving up health insurance coverage.
Currently, 46% of adults in Ireland have private health insurance, a slight increase from 2023, according to the HIA. However, the growing number of cancellations suggests that affordability is becoming a critical factor for a significant portion of the population. This trend could have implications for the public healthcare system, potentially increasing demand for services as more individuals forgo private coverage.
New Tool Aims to Empower Consumers
In response to these findings, the HIA has launched a new free health insurance comparison tool, overseen by the State regulator for private health insurance. HIA chairperson Patricia Byron emphasized the importance of shopping around, stating, “We would strongly encourage consumers to shop around each year when their plan comes up for renewal, and our new comparison tool provides a trusted and accessible starting point.” The HIA website provides access to the new tool and further information on health insurance options in Ireland.
The launch of this tool represents an effort to address the information asymmetry that may be contributing to the low switching rates. By providing a centralized, unbiased platform for comparing plans, the HIA hopes to empower consumers to make more informed decisions and potentially unlock savings. However, the success of this initiative will depend on consumer awareness and willingness to utilize the tool.
The HIA Consumer Survey is conducted every two years, providing a valuable benchmark for tracking trends in the Irish health insurance market. The latest findings underscore the need for greater transparency, increased competition, and continued efforts to educate consumers about their options.
Looking ahead, the HIA will continue to monitor switching rates and consumer sentiment. The next HIA Consumer Survey is scheduled for 2026 and will provide further insights into the evolving dynamics of the Irish health insurance market. Consumers are encouraged to utilize the new comparison tool and actively review their health insurance options during their annual renewal periods.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about health insurance and should not be considered financial or medical advice. Consult with a qualified professional for personalized guidance.
Have your say: Do you regularly shop around for health insurance? Share your experiences and thoughts in the comments below.
Related reading
