Estoril had just lost 3-1 to Sporting at Alvalade, but Ian Cathro wasn’t dwelling on the result. Instead, the 39-year-vintage Scottish coach turned to the journalist and, in fluent Portuguese, asked a question: “What type of football do you like to watch? Did you enjoy the game? Probably you were all around here in other matches and I assume you fell asleep [at some point]. We wish to do things differently.” That moment, recounted by the BBC, encapsulates the bold approach Cathro is bringing to Portuguese football, and it’s a key reason why he’s being hailed as a rising star in the sport. This is a story of rebuilding a managerial reputation, one focused on fearless football and a commitment to stability.
Cathro’s journey hasn’t been a straightforward ascent. After a promising start as a youth coach – influencing players like Ryan Gauld – he quickly moved into assistant roles at high-profile clubs including Valencia and Newcastle United. A brief, and ultimately unsuccessful, stint as head coach of Heart of Midlothian in 2016-2017 left a mark, but it was a difficult one. Now, with Estoril, he’s finding his footing, transforming a team historically battling relegation into a competitive force in the Primeira Liga. The focus on attacking football is paying dividends, with Estoril averaging two goals per game – 46 in 23 matches – more than league leaders FC Porto (44 goals) as of February 2026.
A Different Approach in Portugal
What sets Cathro apart isn’t just the results, but the style. Estoril, playing in a 5,000-capacity stadium, has shown the courage to take the game to larger opponents, even silencing the crowds at stadiums like Alvalade, home to Sporting Lisbon. They’ve scored four or more goals in six games this season, tied with Sporting for the most in the league. Whereas their defense – having conceded 39 goals – remains a work in progress, the attacking prowess is undeniable. This willingness to play without fear, regardless of the opponent, is a philosophy Cathro consistently emphasizes.
“I’m young, but I’ve already been through a lot, in a lot of places,” Cathro told BBC Sport. “I think I’ve already seen almost every film you can notice in a career in this industry.” He isn’t chasing quick wins; he’s building something sustainable. “I’m not here trying to win five games in a row just to produce the jump. I look at this project and I genuinely feel my responsibility is to help the club take a step to another level. And that other level is more stability, so that no one – absolutely no-one – is afraid anymore.”
Recognition from Peers and Rivals
The impact of Cathro’s work hasn’t gone unnoticed. In January, he was voted the Portuguese top flight’s coach of the month by his fellow managers, a significant acknowledgement of his influence. Even Jose Mourinho, the highly respected Benfica boss, has publicly praised Cathro, stating he “is leaving his mark” on the league. This recognition is particularly meaningful given Mourinho’s own storied career and discerning eye for talent.
Cathro’s coaching career began with a focus on youth development. He became the head of Dundee United’s youth academy at just 22 years old, too working with the Scottish Football Association’s youth program. According to his Wikipedia page, Ryan Gauld has specifically cited Cathro as a major influence on his career. This early experience instilled in him a belief in nurturing talent and building a strong foundation.
From Assistant to Head Coach: A Winding Path
The path from youth coach to Primeira Liga manager wasn’t linear. Cathro gained valuable experience as an assistant coach at Rio Ave and Valencia, working alongside Nuno Espírito Santo. He then moved to Newcastle United, initially under Steve McClaren, and was retained by Rafa Benítez when McClaren was sacked in March 2016. The experience at Newcastle, though ultimately not leading to a head coaching role there, exposed him to the demands of the Premier League. His time at Heart of Midlothian, while challenging, provided valuable lessons in leadership and managing expectations.
Estoril’s current position – 33 points from 23 games – suggests they won’t reach the club’s record top-flight points tally of 54 (achieved in the 2013-14 season), but the progress is clear. Cathro is focused on building a team that can consistently compete at the top level, and his emphasis on stability and fearless football is laying the groundwork for future success. He’s often described as “the most Portuguese Scot there is,” a testament to his immersion in the culture and his ability to connect with players and fans alike.
The team’s ability to consistently find the back of the net, coupled with a growing sense of belief, is transforming the atmosphere at Estoril. Cathro’s leadership is fostering a culture where players are encouraged to express themselves and take risks, resulting in an exciting brand of football that is captivating fans in Portugal. The next test comes on Friday as Estoril returns to Alvalade, hoping to build on their progress and secure a positive result against Sporting.
As Ian Cathro continues to rebuild his managerial reputation, his story serves as a reminder that setbacks can be stepping stones to success. His commitment to a bold, attacking style, combined with a focus on stability and player empowerment, is making him one of the most exciting young coaches in European football. The coming weeks will be crucial as Estoril aims to solidify their position in the top half of the Primeira Liga table, with 11 games remaining in the season.
What are your thoughts on Ian Cathro’s impact at Estoril? Share your opinions and predictions in the comments below, and don’t forget to share this article with fellow football fans.
