Rome – Italy’s governing right-wing coalition has presented a bill to overhaul the country’s electoral law, sparking criticism from opposition parties who allege the proposed changes are designed to benefit Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s bloc in the 2027 general election. The proposed reforms, dubbed “stabilicum” by proponents, aim to introduce a more proportional system whereas too providing a “governance bonus” to parties or coalitions that achieve a significant level of voter support.
The core of the proposed legislation, presented to Parliament on Thursday, involves eliminating single-member districts – where the candidate with the most votes wins – and replacing them with a proportional system intended to encourage coalition building. A key element is a bonus of 70 seats in the Chamber of Deputies and 35 in the Senate for the winning party or coalition, provided they secure over 40% of the vote, according to reporting from Corriere della Sera. If no coalition surpasses this threshold, seats will be allocated proportionally, unless the two leading blocs achieve between 35% and 40% of the vote, triggering a runoff election.
The current electoral law, known as Rosatellum, combines proportional representation with a majoritarian component. As El Mundo reported, the Rosatellum system is believed to have aided Meloni’s right-wing coalition in securing a parliamentary majority in the 2022 general election, particularly as the left-wing opposition was fragmented. The new proposal aims to solidify that majority for the anticipated 2027 vote.
Constitutional Concerns and the ‘Governance Bonus’
The proposed “governance bonus” – the additional seats awarded to the winning coalition – has drawn particular scrutiny. The bill stipulates a maximum of 15% of total seats can be allocated through this bonus, translating to a potential 230 seats in the Chamber of Deputies and 114 in the Senate. However, critics point out that this could effectively grant the winning coalition 57.5% of the seats, exceeding the 55% limit previously established by the Constitutional Court as the maximum permissible for majority bonuses.
The Constitutional Court’s previous ruling stipulated that majority bonuses are permissible only if the winning coalition does not control more than 55% of the seats. The proposed legislation’s potential to exceed this threshold raises questions about its constitutionality.
Opposition Accusations and Government Response
Opposition figures have been quick to condemn the proposed reforms. Davide Faraone, a deputy from the Viva Italia party, criticized the “very high majority bonus,” while Elly Schlein, leader of the Democratic Party (PD), accused the government of rushing the legislation through Parliament out of “fear” of an upcoming referendum on judicial reform. Schlein argued the changes could “seriously distort representation” within the country.
The bill also introduces a change to candidate presentation. Coalitions will be required to name their prime ministerial candidates in their platforms, but these names will not appear on the ballot. Voters will instead cast their votes for the coalition or party symbol, removing the ability to directly express a preference for a specific prime ministerial candidate.
Looking Ahead: Referendum and Parliamentary Debate
The proposed electoral reform comes as Italy prepares for a referendum on judicial reform, a separate but potentially related political challenge for Meloni’s government. The timing of the electoral law proposal has fueled speculation that the government is attempting to preemptively secure its position ahead of the referendum, which could impact its broader political agenda.
The bill now enters a period of parliamentary debate and scrutiny. The next key step will be its consideration by the relevant parliamentary committees, followed by a full vote in both the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate. The outcome of this debate will significantly shape the landscape of Italian politics and the dynamics of the 2027 general election. The Italian Parliament is expected to begin committee review of the bill in early March.
Share your thoughts on Italy’s proposed electoral reforms in the comments below.
