A federal judge on Monday ordered the Trump administration to turn over its agreements with nine major law firms and the internal communications behind them, a ruling that could expose how the White House used executive orders to extract hundreds of millions of dollars in pro bono work.
U.S. District Judge Amir Ali granted the American Bar Association’s request for the deals and related emails in a 26-page opinion that rejected the Justice Department’s argument that separation-of-powers principles shielded the records. The case stems from a campaign the administration launched weeks into President Trump’s second term, targeting firms over their past legal work and political associations.
“The communications sought in requests 1, 2, and 7 are directly relevant to whether the government made ‘threat[s] of retaliatory sanctions’ against law firms that would have ‘deterred ABA members and their law firms from engaging in First Amendment protected activity,’” Ali wrote.
The nine firms — Kirkland, Paul Weiss, Skadden, Latham & Watkins, Milbank, A&O Shearman, Simpson Thacher, Willkie Farr, and Cadwalader (now part of Hogan Lovells Cadwalader) — collectively pledged roughly $940 million in free legal services for causes favored by the president, according to court filings and congressional letters reviewed by multiple outlets.
The deals were struck after Trump signed executive orders threatening to suspend security clearances, restrict building access and cancel federal contracts.

“would have considered accepting these sorts of representations, consistent with its past practice, without any agreement with a particular administration.” Kirkland said in a statement.
Kirkland disclosed to Congress that it has done an array of free work for the Trump administration, about 6,491 hours valued at $11.8 million, far short of the $125 million in pro bono commitments Trump announced on social media in April 2025.
The firm said that there was no underlying document that described the terms of the agreement — only Mr. Trump’s social media post announcing the deal. It said that the administration had not asked it for an accounting of whether it had fulfilled its obligations.
“Big Law continues to bend the knee to President Trump because they know they were wrong,” Karoline Leavitt told the Wall Street Journal in April 2025. Leavitt’s statement became a cornerstone of the ABA’s suit; Ali cited it when he denied the government’s motion to dismiss, and again Monday when defining the scope of the document search.

The judge limited the email search to February 13 through April 18, 2025 — the period spanning five executive orders and the nine settlements. An email chain from April 2025 already produced in the case shows White House aides rushing to lift sanctions on Paul Weiss after the firm agreed to $40 million in free work.
“Per POTUS, this EO needs to be ready now,” White House senior policy strategist May Mailman wrote on March 19, 2025, using shorthand for the president and the executive order.
Ali also ordered the administration to produce communications with four firms that were targeted but did not settle: Jenner & Block, Perkins Coie, Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP, and Susman Godfrey. The ABA is represented by Susman Godfrey, which the government sought to disqualify as counsel; Ali rejected that bid.

The ruling comes as the nine firms are expected to face heightened scrutiny in the new Democrat-controlled Congress over the deals, where lawmakers have already sent multiple letters to Kirkland and other firms demanding details of the arrangements. “Shrugs don’t work as well against subpoena power,” Above the Law writer, Katheryn Rubino wrote.
The American Bar Association, founded in 1878 by 75 lawyers in Saratoga Springs, New York, sets academic standards for law schools and formulates model ethical codes for the profession. As of 2024, it reported about 150,000 paying members. The organization’s national headquarters are in Chicago, Illinois, with a branch office in Washington, D.C.
The government can ask him to pause the order while the appeal plays out.