The Erosion of Local Politics: National Issues Dominate State and City Races
The traditional notion that “all politics is local” is increasingly outdated, as national concerns-from presidential figures to international conflicts-are heavily influencing elections at the state and municipal levels.
Recent elections in Virginia, New Jersey, and New York City demonstrate a clear trend: voters are increasingly swayed by national narratives, overshadowing local issues. In Virginia and New Jersey’s gubernatorial races, and particularly in New york City’s mayoral contest, the presence of former President Donald Trump and even international affairs have become central to the campaigns.
The nationalization of politics isn’t a new phenomenon, especially within congress. Heightened partisan polarization has made cross-party voting less common,fueled by animosity between Democrats and Republicans. This trend is compounded by the decline of local news outlets, leaving citizens more informed about-and invested in-national political dynamics than issues closer to home. As an inevitable result, the political landscape has become increasingly nationalized, with local races mirroring national divides.
Historically, regional differences played a larger role in electoral outcomes. A Democrat could once win a House seat in North Dakota, and California might send a Republican to the Senate. Though, political scientist lee Drutman notes that presidential voting patterns now overwhelmingly predict House outcomes-explaining 98% of results, compared to 91% in the Senate. In 2000, candidate quality could swing roughly half of Senate races; by 2024, that figure had plummeted to just 12%.
while governorships and mayoralties are often touted as being more focused on practical governance, national politics is increasingly encroaching on these roles. In Virginia, Democrat Abigail Spanberger is projected to win the governor’s race, continuing a trend-since 1976, the party holding the presidency has lost the Old Dominion governor’s race the following year in all but one instance. The state’s changing demographics are exacerbating this pattern, with a growing number of non-native residents conditioned by national political practices, such as party registration and straight-ticket voting. These voters are highly aware of national figures like Trump,and their opinions are already firmly established.
new Jersey’s gubernatorial race is expected to be closer, with Democrat Mikie Sherrill holding a slight edge over Republican Jack Ciattarelli. Sherrill has actively invoked the former president throughout her campaign,prompting Ciattarelli to mock her approach. However, Trump’s past attempts to obstruct a crucial rail tunnel project connecting New jersey and New York may inadvertently benefit Sherrill.
The nationalization of the New York City mayoral race has been particularly striking. Despite the mayoralty often being considered a political dead-end, the race has been dominated by national issues.The Israeli-Palestinian conflict, in particular, has become a important point of contention, largely due to the background of front-runner Zohran Mamdani, whose pro-Palestinian activism is central to his political identity.His stated willingness to honor an International Criminal Court warrant for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu-a position he likely lacks the legal authority to enforce-has sparked debate
for themselves, Paula Mejía writes.
Play our daily crossword.
PSI don’t mean to make all my postscripts remembrances for musicians-but I didn’t want to let the death of Donna Jean Godchaux-MacKay go unmarked. She was a vocalist with the Grateful Dead for most of the 1970s. Her singing is, let’s say, divisive among Deadheads, and if you listen to live recordings that include her, you’re going to find some cringe moments. But you’ll also find her voice truly enhancing many shows during the band’s best years. check out, such as, May 8, 1977 at Cornell’s Barton Hall, which some people consider the best Dead show ever. Fare thee well, Donna jean.- David
Rafaela Jinich contributed to this newsletter.
When you buy a book using a link in this newsletter,we receive a commission. Thank you for supporting The Atlantic.
