# nativity Scene in massachusetts Sparks Controversy with ‘ICE Was Here’ Display
A Massachusetts church’s unconventional Nativity scene, featuring an “ICE was here” sign in place of teh Holy Family, has ignited a firestorm of debate, raising questions about faith, immigration, and the role of religious institutions in political discourse.
Dedham, Massachusetts – A parish in Dedham is at the center of a growing controversy after its nativity scene was altered to reflect the realities of immigration enforcement in the United States.The display at St. Susanna Parish now features a sign reading “ICE was here,” suggesting the biblical figures of Mary, Joseph, and Baby Jesus were apprehended by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. Below the sign, a message reads, “The Holy Family is safe in our Church… If you see ICE please call LUCE at 617-370-5023.”
The display was conceived by Rev. Stephen Josoma, who explained his intention was to prompt reflection on the treatment of vulnerable populations. “What is the objective by doing this? To help people recognize the plight of people who are really in dire need, and how are we treating them,” he stated. “We’re supposed to bring out the best of people in christmas.”
This is not the frist instance of Rev. Josoma using the Nativity scene to address contemporary social and political issues.He has previously used the display to highlight climate change,advocate for gun control,and,in 2018 during the first term of the Trump presidency,depicted Baby jesus in a cage separated from his parents – a direct reference to the family separation policy at the U.S.-Mexico border.
However, the latest iteration has drawn sharp criticism from some quarters. C.J. Doyle,Executive Director of the Catholic Action League of Massachusetts,condemned the display as a “crackpot political stunt.” He reported receiving complaints from parishioners who found the scene “divisive” and “disrespectful.”
“This is not right, it’s divisive, it’s disrespectful, it takes away from the essential Christmas message,” Doyle said. He expressed hope that the archdiocese would intervene to halt what he views as inappropriate political messaging within a sacred space.”the purpose of a Nativity scene is to remind us of the purpose of Christmas, not to remind us of current political issues,” he added.
Despite the backlash, Rev.Josoma remains steadfast in his decision. He believes the church has a moral obligation to speak out on issues of social justice, especially during the Christmas season. He stated he has received supportive messages from people across the country, including immigrants and advocates.
Why: rev. Stephen Josoma created the display to raise awareness about the plight of immigrants and prompt reflection on how society treats vulnerable populations.
Who: Rev. Stephen Josoma of St. Susanna Parish in Dedham, Massachusetts, conceived the display, while C.J. Doyle of the Catholic Action League of Massachusetts has been a vocal critic.
What: The Nativity scene at St. Susanna Parish was altered to include an “ICE was here” sign and a phone number for a local immigrant advocacy group.
How did it end?: As of the time of this report, Rev. Josoma remains committed to the display despite criticism, and the archdiocese has not intervened. The scene continues to spark debate and discussion within the community and beyond.
