A young family has secured a clinker-brick home in Brunswick East, narrowly edging out an older downsizer in a contest that highlights the current tension within the Melbourne property market. The sale of 57 Ryan Street for $1.02 million serves as a microcosm of a broader trend: while buyers are becoming increasingly cautious, high-quality assets in strategic locations are still triggering competitive bidding.
The property, sold as part of a deceased estate, attracted three bidders who pushed the final price $30,000 above the upper end of the property’s price guide. The winning bidders, who are first-home buyers, managed to beat out both the downsizer and another young couple eager to enter the area. According to Barry Plant Brunswick agent and auctioneer Ben Calcagno, the home’s proximity to Brunswick East Primary School and the inclusion of a recently secured parcel of ex-council land made it a unique offering in an otherwise challenging environment.
The auction began at $875,000 before jumping quickly to $900,000. From there, the bidding settled into a steady rhythm of $10,000 and $5,000 increments until the hammer fell just over the seven-figure mark. The property had a price guide of $900,000 to $990,000 and a reserve of $945,000.
A shifting tide in Melbourne’s auction rooms
The competition in Brunswick East comes at a time when the broader Melbourne market is showing signs of a transition. Domain Group recorded a preliminary auction clearance rate of 56 per cent from 557 reported results out of 822 scheduled auctions for the week. This figure includes 104 withdrawn auctions, which are counted as unsold in clearance calculations.
Industry observers note that interest rate hikes and general economic uncertainty are making buyers more price-sensitive, particularly at the higher end of the market. This sentiment was echoed by Jellis Craig Northcote agent Sam Rigopoulos, who noted that having three active bidders on a single property is currently considered a positive outcome.
Calcagno suggested that the market is beginning to feel more like a buyers’ market. However, he maintained that sellers can still achieve strong results if the product is “priced fairly” and possesses genuine appeal.
Patterns of movement: From sea-changes to family hubs
The recent wave of sales across Melbourne’s suburbs reveals a distinct demographic swap, with “empty nesters” moving toward the coast while young families fight for footholds in established inner-ring suburbs.
In Thornbury, an updated Californian bungalow at 139 Rossmoyne Street sold for its $1,685,000 reserve. The three-bedroom home, featuring polished floorboards and a backyard with a putting green and jacuzzi, was won by a couple with young children moving from Mornington to be closer to family. Conversely, the vendors—empty nesters—are now planning a sea-change back to Mornington, beginning with a holiday in Thailand followed by an Airbnb tour of the peninsula to find their next home.
Similar dynamics played out in Bentleigh East, where a modern three-bedroom townhouse at 71a Stockdale Avenue sold for $1.38 million. The auction was a direct competition between two young families, with the winning couple moving their own children interstate for a lifestyle change. The property had a reserve of $1.3 million and a price guide of $1.15 million to $1.25 million.
Further north in Craigieburn, a four-bedroom home at 98 Golf View Drive sold for $897,500. The buyers, a couple from South Morang, pushed slightly past their $895,000 budget after previously losing a home they had desired, illustrating the emotional premium some buyers are still willing to pay to secure a property in a tight market.
| Suburb | Property Address | Sale Price | Price Guide |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brunswick East | 57 Ryan Street | $1.02 Million | $900k – $990k |
| Thornbury | 139 Rossmoyne Street | $1.685 Million | $1.55m – $1.65m |
| Bentleigh East | 71a Stockdale Avenue | $1.38 Million | $1.15m – $1.25m |
| Craigieburn | 98 Golf View Drive | $897,500 | $840k – $860k |
The impact of ‘unique’ property features
A recurring theme across these sales is the value placed on non-standard features. In Brunswick East, the addition of ex-council land provided a tangible value-add that helped push the price above the guide. In Thornbury, the specific blend of original character—such as brown tiling—and modern luxuries like a jacuzzi helped the property meet its reserve despite a price-sensitive environment.
For first-home buyers, these “unique” factors often become the deciding point in a bidding war. When the pool of available stock in a desired school zone or a quiet pocket is limited, buyers are more likely to stretch their budgets, as seen in the Craigieburn sale.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or real estate investment advice.
Market participants are now looking toward the next round of auction data to see if the 56 per cent clearance rate holds or if the “buyers’ market” sentiment leads to a higher volume of passed-in properties. The next major checkpoint will be the end-of-month aggregate data from major property portals, which will indicate whether price sensitivity is leading to a broader correction in guide prices.
Do you think the Melbourne market has officially shifted in favor of the buyer? Share your thoughts in the comments or share this story with someone currently hunting for a home.
Keep reading
