Shohei Ohtani‘s Historic Home Run Balls Could Fetch Millions at Auction
A potential seven-figure windfall awaits the fans who caught the three home run balls hit by Shohei Ohtani during last Friday night’s National League Championship Series game, according to leading auction experts. The historic memorabilia is estimated to be worth $3 million or more each, fueled by Ohtani’s unprecedented performance and the soaring market for sports collectibles.
Published October 21, 2025, at 12:50 AM PDT
Those fortunate enough to secure a piece of baseball history may soon discover the true value of their catch. One prominent auction expert indicated to TMZ Sports that each ball could command a price tag in the millions.
David kohler, founder of SCP Auctions, stated on Monday that if he were to offer one of the historic Ohtani mementos at auction, he would anticipate a sale price of “$3 million or more.” This staggering estimate is not without precedent, considering a home run ball hit by Ohtani last year ultimately sold for $4.39 million.
In fact,Kohler expressed he wouldn’t be surprised if one of the balls from the National League Championship Series clincher fetched an even higher price. “The market is primed to capitalize on the crowning achievement of the most dominant athlete in the world today,” Kohler said.
Ohtani’s remarkable Game 4 performance against the Brewers included three home runs – hit in the bottom of the first, fourth, and seventh innings – alongside six innings of scoreless baseball and 10 strikeouts. This remarkable display elevates the potential value of any artifacts from the game.
The identity of the fan who caught the first home run ball remains unknown. However, David Flores, a 35-year-old boxing trainer, publicly claimed on his Instagram page that he caught the third Ohtani home run. Carlos Mendoza, 26, stated he secured the second one, according to reports from USA Today.
[Waiting for your permission to load the Instagram Media.]
While Mendoza initially expressed a desire to return the ball to Ohtani, a potential seven-figure payout could quickly alter those plans. Flores has already indicated his intention to sell his souvenir.
Here’s a visual recap of Ohtani’s incredible night:
Shohei Ohtani’s Historic Home Run Balls Could Fetch Millions at Auction
@TalkinBaseball_
The escalating value of Ohtani memorabilia reflects his growing status as a global sports icon and the increasing demand for rare and significant collectibles. As the market continues to respond to his achievements, these home run balls represent a unique chance for collectors and investors alike.
Why did this happen? Shohei Ohtani hit three home runs in Game 4 of the National League Championship Series against the Brewers, alongside a dominant pitching performance. This unprecedented achievement, combined with his existing status as a global sports icon, dramatically increased the value of memorabilia from the game.
Who was involved? The key players are shohei Ohtani, the three fans who caught his home run balls – David Flores (third ball), Carlos Mendoza (second ball), and one
