Ontario Farmers Face Uncertainty as Government Pursues Massive Radar Project
Table of Contents
A $38-billion investment to upgrade Canada’s North American Aerospace defense System (NORAD) commitment is sparking anxiety and resistance in rural Ontario, as the Department of National Defense (DND) seeks to acquire vast tracts of farmland for a new radar installation. Residents of clearview Township and the Kawartha Lakes region are grappling with the possibility of losing their properties – some farmed for generations – to make way for the Arctic Over-the-Horizon Radar (A-OTHR) project.
The situation began this summer when the DND sent letters to dozens of landowners, inquiring about their willingness to sell land for the project. The DND is seeking to acquire approximately 1,600 hectares (4,000 acres) of prime agricultural land in Clearview Township, near Stayner, Ontario. A second site is planned for the Kawartha Lakes region. The facilities would include massive transmit and receive stations, encircled by rows of antennas and a six-meter-high barbed wire fence.
The DND has already purchased approximately 280 hectares in the area, but requires hundreds more to make the project viable. while the department insists it is committed to “mutually beneficial” acquisitions with “fair compensation,” residents remain skeptical, fearing potential expropriation if they refuse to sell.
Generations of Farming at Risk
The uncertainty is especially acute for families with deep roots in the community. Matt Hutchison, a fifth-generation farmer, expressed his despair. “My family has been here since 1879 on this property, and I’m the fifth generation to take over, and my son is hopefully gonna be the sixth generation,” Hutchison said. “It’s hard to deal with knowing that we might lose it all.”
His wife, Jennifer Hutchison, echoed his concerns, describing a paralyzing sense of limbo. “We’re at a standstill. we don’t know what to do. Do we move forward with our future plans that we’ve had?” she said. “We’re just kind of sitting here in limbo and farmers don’t limbo.Do we plan to move forward and keep working hard? You just wonder why.”
Limited Answers from Ottawa
Local officials and residents report a lack of clarity from the government. Beyond an initial community meeting, facts about the project’s progression has been scarce. Terry Dowdell, the area’s Member of Parliament, stated he has repeatedly pressed officials in Ottawa for clarity on how the DND will proceed if landowners decline to sell. “It’s a lot of money that the government’s putting into this property without getting that commitment,” Dowdell said. “And would they still go forward? And I still don’t have an answer 100 per cent.” As of now, only one property owner has agreed to a sale, according to Dowdell.
the DND maintains it is “not currently working on expropriation of land plans,” but this assurance has done little to quell anxieties.
Farmland Loss and Economic Impact
the potential loss of 4,000 acres of farmland is raising concerns about the broader economic impact on the region.Clearview Township Mayor Doug Measures emphasized the importance of preserving agricultural land. “Taking 4,000 acres out of production will moast definitely have a ripple effect across our whole community,” Measures said. “A farmer will purchase goods from local suppliers, stores. But all of those jobs will eventually be impacted as you cut back on fewer and fewer farmers.”
The DND has justified the site selection based on “complex and inflexible requirements,” including latitude, flat dry land, and distance from radio noise sources. Though, Dowdell and others question whether the area truly meets these criteria, particularly given its recent growth.
Residents are left waiting, hoping for answers and bracing for the possibility of losing their livelihoods and a way of life that has spanned generations. “We have no idea,because they’re not giving us answers,” Jennifer Hutchison said,through tears.”We’re waiting for another envelope to show up in the mailbox.”
